Jesus doesn't know shit about guns, they just threw spears. If you want a .357, get the revolver and the S&W is ok. If you want a 9mm semiauto I don't like glocks, they feel too "tinny", I'd go for an STI. If you really want a 357 semiauto then try magnum research

They're both good. Smith and Wesson .357 is a revolver. Glock 19 is 9mm semiautomatic. It depends on what you want it for. Don't pray to Jesus unless it'll keep you from shooting somebody or yourself.

I guess it depends on what you're trying to accomplish. But I only have experience with a Taurus 357 magnum.