Agnostic.com

77 8

Do you find it offensive when theist think without a belief in god/gods, it’s impossible to have morality?

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

77 comments (51 - 75)

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

Nah... But I tend to respond with ideas they find offensive.

Oh... So without god you would have no moral code? So you're not giving me an argument for god you are merely admitting that you are unethical trash beneath me because you require punishment to enforce decency, am I getting that about right?

When I hear that the bible was written by men inspired by god I suggest the writing on the bathroom wall could be equally inspired. They don't usually care for that. LOL

1

I find it very offensive. One is basically saying you are not a human being. The fact is, everyone has morals. Even inside prison there is a moral code. Morals are a part of humanity and can be either bad or good.

Punch Level 4 June 2, 2018
1

Not, really, only a non-critical thinker sees the world in a dichotomy. I will point out that the concepts are not mutually exclusive, one can be critical of religion and be a moral person. If they are not receptive, I ask myself, do I want to waste time (that I can never get back) attempting to broaden the mind that is like a steel trap (closed so that nothing gets in). I have the choice to be pulled into their ignorance or move on...

1

More than anything, I am sorry fiction has shaped somebody's view of reality to that extent. Ignorance, just by itself. doesn't offend me. It saddens me.

1

I can't really say as I've never been confronted with it first hand but I don't think I'd find it offensive as it's nonsense

1

My answer revolves around not being able to screw up and pray to have my sins wiped away. Atheists are required to get it right in one, it's what makes us such great people.

1

I don’t find it offensive.. but it is incredible stupid. it just means that they would choose to have no morality cuz they are psychopaths hiding behind false morality.

1

Nothing is impossible. I've run a marathon.hiked the Grand canyon, know people that have run a business using just a bicycle for transportation and done other incredible things. Beliefs don't really factor into morality,you can only try to good within reason. I believe in moral proximity (help when you can and have the means).

1

No. Just shows they're ignorant, and willfully so.
But then that's religion in a nut shell.

1

Being offended is unhealthy and unnecessary. If you are going to buck the crowd you know in advance that you’ll get flak from some quarters.

I suppose a person could make a big whoop-de-doo over being different and superior just for ego purposes, and in that case, being offended would certainly be useful in keeping the ego cauldron boiling.

I do not call myself an atheist, but my opinion is that morality is purely subjective. A good person is one who acts as I wish him to act—an evil person does what I don’t like.

Actually, IMO good and evil are not opposites. Evil exists only in imagination, while good has true essence, and permeates the universe.

@OroLee Well said. You are probably right.

1

I do not take offense at what other people think. What other's think is none of my business, does not concern me and does not affect me. It is their actions and what they do that has an affect on anyone.

1

Seems to me religion follows social norms of society and bases their current teachings on what is currently acceptable. Where was any Christian church on treatment of the Jews and black people in the early part of the 20th century? If they are the light and the truth shouldn’t their teachings and beliefs be timeless and unaffected by current social or political norms? Ridiculous

1

It's the difference between being a decent person, and just acting like one for fear of reprisals from an all seeing entity.

Broadly speaking, you're either a decent person or you're not. If you're not, then religion stands a chance of keeping you on track. Though there are plenty of god believers who are also nasty people and/or criminals. So it's not that effective a deterrent, is it? It certainly doesn't seem to stop Catholic priests performing sex offences against children.

1

Mostly I amazed that people can be that stupid.

0

Theists don't think, they believe.

zesty Level 7 July 9, 2019
0

yes. also frustrated. it happens a lot online. face to face, the worst i have had to endure recently was someone's assuring me that atheism is a religion.

g

0

Haven't we had enough with the offended whatever? No, I am not offended. People can do whatever they want as long as it doesn't interfere with my personal space. If that happens to be the case then instead of being offended how about a sucker punch? (Just being ridiculous nonsensical because I can 🙂 )

0

I think that it is a little bit offencive but mostly I find it ignorant and arrogant on their part.

0

Response to the titled statement as read yes or no, prior to reading specificity of nature.....imagine yourself as the thiest, who's just boosted the spiritual ego....enlightened seem to spread light......you've been handpicked by the theist to discuss and debate! Advance the upward gravety of gnosis

StephD Level 4 June 11, 2018
0

Nope

0

I believe that here in the U.S. all people have the right to believe as they wish. Beliefs,skin color,educational levels all factor into the persons character but do not define it. I live an active lifestyle,try to be friendly and mostly succeed in not judging others. As for morality; I believe there is right and wrong,good and bad. Each person is unique and should live the life they enjoy!

0

I'm amused.

0

I wouldn't say it's offensive, but it is certainly annoying for its innate stupidity, and it doesn't encourage intelligent politics when people think these things and find other excuses to pander to religion. However, theists have an exceedingly large amount of people without the faintest clue on how to disseminate a true belief versus a false one, so I am not surprised they think these things.

0

No.

Coldo Level 8 May 30, 2018
0

I don't find it offensive. It's wrong and silly, but it's just how they think.

I do my best to be good and the opinions of people who believe in religion are the very least of my worries.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:94301
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.