I decided I would give an update for those who are interested. Last week I posted here about a Muslim girl I met online. I asked her out despite her religion, and lets just say it didn't go very well.
I tried to steer the conversation away from religion as much as possible, but she just kept bringing it back. It seemed like she just really wanted to argue about it, and it didn't help that she was even more intelligent than I anticipated. At one point I started talking about my old job and how terrible my boss was, just trying to tell relatable stories, and she shook her head and then asked me if I thought morality was universal or relative... It was as if she just wouldn't allow there to be any common ground between us.
Thanks everyone for the advice anyways, It was greatly appreciated even though the end result wasn't that great!