Agnostic.com

9 11

From The Daily Stoic on Why wear a mask?

The world has asked a lot of us over the last few months. We had to stop traveling. We had to shut down our businesses. We had to take our kids out of school.

It asked even more of some of us. The doctors who had to work round-the-clock shifts. The nurses who did the same. There are those among us whose businesses will never reopen or whose jobs will never come back. There are some of us who didn’t get to say goodbye to people we loved, who had to watch funerals over the internet.

In a beautiful article a few weeks ago, Steven Pressfield (who we interviewed here) spoke about how the Spartans—the ancient Greeks who the Stoics admired so much—would have responded to this kind of collective sacrifice. He quotes Plutarch, who explained why the Spartans punished with death the soldier who dropped his shield but not his other protective gear, “Because helmet and breastplate are worn to protect the individual alone but the shield is borne to protect the whole line.”

“Why are we asked to wear surgical or face masks in public, to practice social distancing, and to observe self-quarantining?” Steven asked. “Answer: Because these practices are not for the individual alone but for the protection of the whole line.”

This moment we are in is a test. It’s a test of your character. It’s a test of your Stoicism. It’s asking whether you just pay lip service to sympatheia, or whether you actually believe it—whether you can embody your philosophy as Epictetus said. We talked about this with John Brownstein: The mask is not for you. Social distancing is not for you. It’s for the grandmother of the person you never met. It’s for the chemo patient. It’s because you might be a carrier and not know it, and so in wearing a mask, you protect the strangers you see and the strangers they see too. In deciding to eat the deposit on your family vacation, to pay for extra sick leave for your workers, to donate to a food bank, you are not helping yourself—you are doing something far more important and more noble.

You are protecting the whole line. And as a Stoic, as a Spartan, as a Citizen of the world, that is your job.

Mitch07102 8 June 15
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

9 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1
2

Living in a land that claims "mateship" but doesn't require face mask wearing, I find this article pungently appropriate.

1

Masks are required in this county and most everybody wears one. I wear one outside all the time due to my allergy to pollen which is high right now. The stores have big signs saying masks are required and, as I drove by the old garden store a large bear model even had a mask. The HS graduation just had a graduation. It was held in the village square and people drove by and honked. The students all had masks. The next day there was a silent/still Blacklivesmatter protest. Also all wearing masks.

2

Accurate depiction

bobwjr Level 10 June 15, 2020
4

I struggle to understand why this is such a difficult concept for people to realize. It is such a small, painless act, yet can do so much good. Seems like a no brainer to me.

I agree. Freedom without responsibility is chaos and the despot's dream. The naive view of those on the alt-right of what freedom actually is, is disconcerting.

"the entire concept of liberty lies in the Non-Aggression Principle, the equivalent of the Silver Rule: do not harm others; they in turn should not harm you."

@Mitch07102 My boys went to a Montessori school and that was their mantra: With freedom comes great responsibility. Far too many conveniently drop the responsibility part but earnestly still cite their inherent freedom, and it irks me to no end. Happy to say even my millennials are wearing their masks when they venture out. Admittedly, their mom is a nurse and if they weren't making the right choices with this one they would be hearing about it, but thus far my intervention has not been required.

Even if it achieved little or nothing, and it does a lot more than that, what is the cost ?

@Fernapple Exactly. It harms no one and is only a net plus. I just don't get the 'freedom' argument of resistance.

3

I love this!

Ohub Level 7 June 15, 2020
5

When I'm at the grocery store and only about a 3rd of the people wear masks, I often loudly say to someone wearing a mask, " Thank you for protecting me with your mask, I'm old." If a conversation ensues I try to add" The sooner we all wear a mask, the sooner none of us will have to wear a mask."

4

True. Though actually it does protect you a little tiny bit too. So being selfish and being socially responsible are not always opposites.

4

♥️♥️♥️🙌🙌🙌

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:506225
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.