Agnostic.com

15 20

How many of you became atheists because you were "Holy Ghosted"?

It happened to me all though my childhood.

snytiger6 9 May 17
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

15 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

2

Papa saved me from all that by telling me the stories of Odin who made things happen for himself.

1

Story of my young adult life. Atheism freed me from the tears.

1

I never really did it honestly.

Lucky you. Many of us were born into religious families.

2

Probably happened to more than a few

bobwjr Level 10 May 18, 2021
2

No, I have never asked any imaginary god for anything, and since I have asked for nothing, I have received it in abundance.

2

I know the feeling. If you were "holy ghosted" it's just because you did not make believe hard enough. I'm telling you, they make it all up.

2

When my prayers went unanswered I would belame myself for not being good enough.

That's how the con works. Yep.

Yes. If you ever discuss your lack of faith or belief with a church leader, they will tell you that you are the one at fault. They will tell you that you must have done something wrong. They try to guilt you into submission.

@snytiger6 The weak always give in.

2

So many times as a child. We were told about the starving children in Africa and so in Sunday School we would pray for them and even collect money for them. I used to pray for them at night if we did prayers with my parents before bed.

Nothing changed.

I remember with great clarity one day when I woke up with a sore ear (Sunday) there was the usual bustle to get us all ready for church etc.

Through the service it kept getting worse, I was in agony, I willed the "spirit of the lord" to come and help me I visualised the images in the windows coming down to touch my ear and make the pain go away. I focused on that happening so hard (so I would not burst into tears) when the service finished I walked out to the car and did burst into tears the next few hours were full of parents looking after me and the next day an antibiotic jab in the bum and ear drops for a while which did a lot more than all of my prayers on the Sunday.

I was less than 7 years old I pretty much got shirty on god after that. How hard was it to fix my ear?

2

wholly ghosted

2

This is my comparison to getting holy ghosted.

It’s like throw the Mother Goose nursery rhyme book in front of you and someone saying you better believe every word of this or I’m gonna blow your brains out. You say yes i believe and then that the person for not blowing your brains out and everytime you question what’s in the book you remember you’ll get your brains blown out for doing that and stop

1

Same here, and developing Type 1 Diabetes regardless of me being otherwise healthy was the final straw.

4

When I want to feel the holy ghost, I just stand under a fan on a hot day and get that chill down my spine.

4

Nope. It was just the absurdity of it all…….The Noah’s Ark thing that began around age 9 or 10.

"It was just the absurdity of it all……." that's all I needed. No other explanation required.

Wait! You don't believe that god drew animals two by two from Alaska to get on a wooden boat in the Middle East and safely got them there to get on that Ark? If god drew animals this way from all over the world how long would it take? No wonder Noah was so old.

3

Very simple. In the words of George Carlin, I reached the age of reason. It was in my 20s. I quit going to church at 14, and over the next few years I came to realize what a sham it was.

Should’ve prayed to Joe Pesci 😉

@Mvtt Not a Pesci fan.

@Sticks48 reference for those playing at home:

6

No, not that any of my prayers were answered, but I left it all to the wisdom of God because what I wanted might not be in his plan.
What got me was the clarity of science and the fraud of scriptures and that still wasn't even enough.
So I'd go to church until the ignorance was too great to endure.
So perhaps there was a version of Christianity that wasn't bullshit, so I studied gnosticism and the beliefs of Cathars and other mystic heretics.
Gnosticism is like quantum mechanics for Christianity, and like quantum mechanics I couldn't get it to work for me. Obviously there's no "Gnosis" (enlightenment) in practical terms. That led to studying mysticism in general, like the teachings of Buddhism, and Sufism, still no luck.
Then at long last after looking through every millimeter of Christianity and all related subject matter I finally could call Christianity out for the BS it always was and became an atheist.
It only took me 50 years or so to divorce myself from it and even now I see things like Trump and all the Christians giving him fellatio and remember verses like "And for this cause God shall send them strong delusion, that they should believe a lie:" and the fear of the anti-Christ returns.
I mean Trump is a beast, but the question for Christians should be "Is he THE Beast?"
He's certainly qualified, far more so than Obama whom they accused of being "THE Beast".
But that's just post religion PTSD on my part.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:597167
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.