Agnostic.com

200 18

Why do you reject the idea of religion?

Admin 9 June 19
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

200 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

19

Religion is a mental illness.

Teresa Level 6 Oct 16, 2017

I agreed.

I also agree.

Well, since auditory experiences and hallucinations are common among the extremely religious people, I would say that in some cases religion and schizophrenia are closely related

@DUCHESSA I’ve met people who told me that they actually hear the voice of God in their heads. If that isn’t disturbing, I don’t know what is.

A well organized mental illness where people make money.

@EmeraldJewel - My neighbour hears god - OUTLOUD. Reminds me of Son of Sam. Scary and disturbing.

@Teresa disturbing.

I don't know if you jest or if you are serious. It by definition is a delusion. In psychology it fits the definition of delusion but gets a nice exemption from diagnosis. Group think is the major cause of religious thinking. When many people share the same delusion then perfectly sane people can buy into it. A good example is Orson Wellls Radio program of War of the Worlds.

We should just start referring to churches as insane asylums.

@DavidLaDeau - I believe honestly that it is a mental illness, I can understand being deluded before you have someone point out fact and non- fact, proof and absence of proof. When they radio announce it was a spoof everyone stopped - with religion when someone proves something else they deny it. I mean my neighbour thinks one of every sex of every dinosaur was on the arc and they starved to death because then they were all vegetarian dinosaurs.

@Teresa That's funny actually...Evidently your neighbor has not considered that his God did not know or plan for that....

@DavidLaDeau The saddest part is she believes EVERYTHING is per-determined so when he daughter passed away in a car accident she has been praying to god for an answer to why for the last six years and posted on FB last week. " The only joy I know is knowing I am one day closer to seeing you again" Since she has a husband, and 2 other kids and 4 or 5 grandchildrne, how can a post liek that make them feel.. Soooo sad.

7

Like the concept of Santa, I outgrew the need for a god.

LOL

I wonder if SANTA and SATAN are the same bloke with the N moved over ??

1

I believe in each persons right to find God their own way. I believe Judaic based religions are based in falsehood

What reason do you have to believe any God exists?

1

I don't reject the idea of religion I reject the practice of religion. I reject kids not getting medical treatment because an old book tells them God will heal all things if you pray hard enough. I reject children being taught that science is BS and it's just a bunch of men in white coats grabbing at grant money. And many more things

LOL . . . here in the Phileippines, and maybe elsewhere, medical schools run by religious institutions are looking deep into the phenomena of psychic healing because there are so many so-called "faith healers" here in my country. And just like the thousands of religious groups registered in our Securities and Exchange Commission, these faith healers have long been doing good business. I tend to envy these guys whenever I have to scrape the bottom of my rice pot. to feed my family

SonnyMIAPH You said you envied those people who scammed money when you're scraping the bottom of your rice pot to feed your family. I just want to say that I respect you more for scrapping the bottom of your rice pot and I know respect doesn't feed your family, but it's not nothing either. You're a leader to our future, every parent is and the shitty part here is I can't offer you a glorious reward in an afterlife for your efforts I can just say thanks.

oh, thank you so much Paul1967 for those very kind and generous remarks . . . I just hope the others won't accuse us of "scratch my back I'll scratch yours, too!" ha-ha-ha!

A long time ago an old friend of mine who happen to be a priest saw me profusely smoking a cigarette on the far side of chapel's yard, approched me and asked, "hey kid, what seem to be problem?"
I replied, "so many bills to pay, been struggling "under" for several months now."
Priest, "a gov't rank-and-file employee like would really find it hard to make ends meet. Why not make a "born again christian ministry" of your own, you know it's the best business in the world and very popular here (Philippines). I'll lend you my other sound system and you can take the second corner from here that has a better pedestrian traffic. I'll have two of my guys and their young sisters assist you with donations one for each corner of that intersection. Hand your calling cards/flyers to all passersby. When you've enough following you can rent a cheap apartment unit as your group's chapel and that's it, it will snowball"

19

Religion began as a way for primitive humanity to explain the unexplainable. As we as a species and as a society have evolved, gained knowledge and found the true scientific explanations for natural phenomena, religion has refused to evolve along with us, and refused to concede to evidence of truth in the process. I cannot have blind faith (or ANY faith) in a group which chooses the comfort of what they want to believe to be true over the evidence that is right in front of them. Futhermore, the practice of religion is fraught with hypocrisy when it comes to morals. Those people who claim to leave judgement to their "god" are the very same people who do not live by the ideals which they preach. The idea that a person needs religion to be moral is as disgustingly hypocritical as it is just plain wrong.

Loved your post. The only thing is I'm pretty sure 'blind faith' is redundant. 😉

Great post...very succinct and absolutely true.

I think religion is progressive. All of the major revealed religions follow each other in a chronological order, the pattern is not difficult to discern. They are links in one unbroken chain.

The reasons why some people do not advance and instead remain attached to the dispensation of their choosing, are many and varied, but it is they that are refusing to evolve, not religion itself.

18

In my late 30’s I began a degree in Theology. I had been a “born again” protestant christian for about 20 years, with a childhood background in catholicism.
My aim in my degree was to major in Pastoral care and counselling with a view to working in that kind of area. I did finish the major studies which I loved and learned more about my self than I thought possible. However I came unstuck when I began on biblical studies.

I discovered that the bible and Jesus simply do not stand up under the rigours of academic enquiry. The bible and the life of the christ are based on myth at best and hearsay/outright lies at worst.

I realised I could not believe this stuff and maintain my personal integrity at the same time. I entered possibly the the worst period of my life, it felt like an abyss. Fortunately it only took about 6 mths to work my way through it and I have been an atheist for more than 20 years now.

Excellent post.

I have always questioned religion (my parents were fairly progressive people). But when I came to the conclusion that there was no God as an adult, I found myself feeling a bit of a loss. But I got over it , it wasn't the worst time in my life fortunately.

You nailed it, Veronica. I too grew up a roman catholic, with strict adherence to all the dogma. And in my late teens, early twenties I took religious studies and retreats alongside religious novitiates to strngthen my faith. It ended up cracking it wide open.
I felt as though I had fallen off a cliff, it was a very scary few months. Until I realised that the world worked quite well without a deity, in fact, it worked better.
Devout atheist ever since.

3

I no longer think about it enough to really reject it. Religion is not only highly improbable, it is also impossibly boring. There are so many more interesting ideas to think, talk and write about. I'm amazed that it captures so many people.

How long did it take you to get to the point where you no longer think about it? Also, I would ask, why join a community such as this, if that were true? (I realize that may sound rude, but I assure you, I mean no Ill will, just curious.) 🙂

@jayknostic I don't think about it much. I was wrong but I assumed when I joined most people would be talking about stuff other than religion.I wasnt thinking about all the recovery issues related to religion

13

I grew up in a pentecostal home, with a mother who is still the "music director/pianist" for the church.

I've seen it all man... "speaking in tounges", "slayn in the spirit", endless rants and endless days or evenings of "worship"... I was grounded if I didn't go to church 3 times a week.

So many stories...

I was taught about Hell as a toddler, and terrified of it, and all that goes with it.

I was taught that if you read anything other than the Bible, you'd be "in danger of Hell fire"... so many more things...

The christian religion has drivin my mother loopy, I can barely stand to be around her, and that's sad to me, because I love her.

When I was 18, I was hit by a truck and awoke from a 2 week coma... I was given a copy of "The be here now" and I started the life long research into "what, where, who, why, when, how, religion came to be in the first place...and it's been 24 years of it now...and I'm still continuing to expand my mind every day.

"Religion" is like a disease to me. It has destroyed my relationship with most of my family, because I have enough sense to think for myself.

That being said, I don't need to be religious to be a loving, kind, thoughtful, charitable, empathetic man.

Must be hard when you have a family of believers.

3

It's a story and it has never made any sense to me.

Most, if not all of the songs, music, poetry and the arts are inspired by man's religious beliefs. There's also the wisdom behind the laws of every land based on their nation's religious beliefs, ecumenical or something like that.

If religion doesn't make any sense, you have to, and it's a must, that you take a real hard look deep into yourself. If you don't want to call it spiritual then call it self-development.

Nothing religious about that, don't you think?

@SonnyMlaPH must? Sorry, I don't do must. It might be a different story if it was offered as advice.

1

Believe in each persons right to find God

how true, oh, so true . . . and you may also call that "respect"

2

It basically rejects the idea of making people think logically and rationally, instead, it indoctrinates things and stuff that cannot be proven just by referring to a book that underwent hundreds of revisions, additions, interpretations and again, revisions.

that's true, so true. As my dad used to say, "I won't bet my life on The Bible (or religion)"

they prefer stupidity, better profits that way.

2

It's toxic to pretty much everything it touches. Religious people start wars whereas atheists rarely (of course, there are exceptions). Religious people - and this includes other "religions" like veganism, pro-GM, anti-GM... pro-organic, pro-choice, anti-choice etc. try to force their worldview on others. This is a very bad thing and it needs to be stopped.

Draco Level 6 Sep 23, 2017

They kill in the name of their god. Some religious groups, believing that they'r only passing through in this lifetime just seem to be waiting peacefully to get slaughtered

1

Religion seems to be a method to describe things that are too complex for us to truthfully understand and accurately describe. Reality is scary, unfair, and disgusting. While at the same time it is lovely, humorous, and rewarding. In our primitive times, we needed a crutch, and many of us still need a crutch.

Religion is objectively a group with many subgroups, and also is used to divide. It has it's pros and cons. People who are part of a religion are more likely to be treated with respect, care, concern, support, etc. within that group. Those outside of that group will likely not receive those same perks from that group.

We can go much more into this putting in the concepts of structural functionalism, social constructionism, and social conflict theory, but that would be a little too much for now. The idea of religion is something that I have walked away from personality.

Still, if it wasn't for religion, our history would have been much different which again, has its pros and cons. Many charitable and altruistic traditions are rooted in religions, so that is a plus from my perspective.

may i add that most if not all of the constitutions and laws of the nations of the world are based on their religious baliefs. . . if only those religious elders would practice what they preach

no pros just cons. I can not find very much logic in your way of thinking. Charitable altruistic traditions blah blah blah be serious. your mind goes all over.

5

It is the single most damaging thing to free thought ever to be invented!

religion rules by fear of a jealous and selfish god

yes it is

4

I see people suffering in the countries i toured. Was i just lucky to be me? Why would god high 5 me and step back on other's? Does suffering build character? Who cares! People need real help and love and compassion. Why should they have to cry and beg and make promises. Damn.

My husband and I have been fortunate to be able to travel quite extensively. When I saw the poverty in many places we travelled, I realized there was not much I could do, I am not a millionaire ( a thousandaire ) then I found out about KIVA and have made small business loans to people in over a dozen countries, some as small as $75.00 but it made all the difference in their lives ( and mine, against all biblical stands I do take pride in helping others ) and so far no one has defaulted on a loan.

@Teresa. That sounds great.... your very kind hearted.

2

What I reject is the delusional mentality of religions' practitioners, not the idea.

I agree with you bro, manipulative, as my dad say, "they don't practice what they preach"

1

There is no actual evidence to support anything supernatural. The Randi Foundation's $million was never claimed.

p433 Level 1 Sep 20, 2017

yes, even the dice experiments of Dr.J.B.Rhine are now in question

2

I don't believe in heaven or hell and I think the bible is just a collection of stories someone made up. There are too many people who take it literally. Nobody rises from the dead!

Snakes do not talk, a flower can not make a woman pregnant.
After a person is dead, it is dead.

8

God/gods are created by men to control men.

0

First is the evidence thing, of which there is none, and second is when you realize that religions were made up by humans for a purpose. That purpose was for early state societies to exert a moral code, or a means of social control over the population.

1

For me the pendulum has now swung in both directions. I spent more than 40 years very active in a demanding church and held leadership positions. Then, in January of 2014, my wife and I abruptly resigned our membership due to finding on YouTube that the history claims of the church were a mountain of lies. My eyes were also opened to the fact that the entire Noah story is incomprehensible and impossible. So, for the past few years I've concluded, 'There is no one God, but there does seem to be great evidence for a universal consciousness in the Universe. Then... a few months ago... I read the first two books by Robert Monroe, and the "Journeys Out of the Body" by William Buhlman, and I was blown away. Finally, something that makes perfect sense and clearly answers almost all of the questions I had. The great thing was, I was able to read the book "Journeys Out of the Body" without having to spend a penny... as that it's free, online, as a PDF. So, I still don't believe there's just one 'God', but now it makes perfect sense that we are progressing through dimensions, and we're in this one right now because it is the most dense and has the lowest frequency, and are here to learn. (Damned cool book.)

I will also add, here, that in my opinion every person who has left religion will find at least some of the answers they are seeking in the William Buhlman book. (If you need any further motivation... Chapter 15 of one of the Robert Monroe books is titled, "Astral Sex". 😉

0

I went to Catholic Elementary school-complete with Hell-Fire paddle wielding nuns who would try to whack your little ass into anything they couldnt talk it into........

I was lucky. I was born into an atheist family. Public school for me.

1

The audacity that individuals think that their religion is the correct one . The war and hatred that it produces. The ridiculous things that they believe in. The brainwashing that they impose on their children

4

I don't. I reject literalist interpretations of religions, because, in addition to being potentially dangerous, they obscure the wisdom to be found in a metaphorical interpretation.

skado Level 9 Nov 26, 2017

Yes, religion if we must have it should certainly be taken as metaphorical. I also think that there would be so many great brains in heaven at least one of them would have been able to communicate with us by now in some way.

0

I don't reject religion, since I was a young lad it never made sense to me!

I remember rejecting religion somewhere between ages 7 and 10. I was interested in astronomy and I knew there was no room for "Heaven" up there.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:15
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.