Agnostic.com

11 4

What Made You Turn Your Back On God? She asked.

I answered. "It is impossible to turn your back on God, because he doesn't exist. What made you turn your back on Zeus?"

#god
By anonymous7
Actions Follow Post Like

Post a comment Add Source Add Photo

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

11 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

How can I turn my back on something that does not exist.

noworry28 Level 7 Dec 10, 2017
0

which god is my first response, then almost the same answer you gave, about zeus, or thor, or odin, or the other 1000 dead gods.

1

Well in my case I was taught to fear god. My mother used it as a threat-for bad behavior. God's going to punish you she would taunt me. I saw nothing good/beneficial of a god-my mother's god-who allowed heinous historical events like the Crusades, Spanish Inquisition and the Holocaust. Her god did absolutely nothing to stop those religious tragedies.

1

The moment I realized he didn't exist I turned my back on God. The problem was, now I didn't know where to aim my back...

That's quite a problem you got there. smile001.gifsmile001.gifsmile001.gif

1

I want to ask... What made you settle on your faith? Have you not noticed there are lots of religions out there? Why do you think yours is the one and only right one? Let me guess. It’s the one your parents were in. Maybe you switched from one church to another but it’s still pretty much the same stuff! Also it’s the main faith in your country, so you’ve never taken the time or showed any interest in learning about what others believe. Have you ever REALLY questioned the stuff they want you to believe, or do you just have FAITH in the weirdness?

2

I don't consider I turned my back... to me it just disappeared as an entity in front of my eyes and the chains were removed allowing me to fly without any weight.

2

You can't turn your back on something that doesn't actually exist. Only in your figment of your imagination it does.

1

I think I'd take the question a little differently. The question about what changed my mind is probably the underlying question, and I'd be inclined to explain myself on that point in hopes that it would resonate with the other person and get them thinking about what they believe and why.

resserts Level 8 Dec 8, 2017
2

This was a response I gave a Christian friend of mine who asked the same question.

I was recently asked by an old friend who knew me as a devoted Christian, what happened? “You had such a wonderful relationship with God. He was your father and we could all see how much you loved him and how he loved you.”

This is my response.

I didn't move away from God as you put it, or backslide, or run away because I was angry. The God that I believed in was never there in the first place. My belief was challenged by real events in the real world—which forced me to look beyond the belief and into reality itself and deal with what was true and what was just made up. By letting go of that belief in God, in computer terms, I simply uninstalled an application that tried to take over my hardware and not allow me to function as I was meant to function.

As to the “father” … in my mind I had created the perfect father based on deficits in my own life. That father was passionate, gentle, hilarious, creative, sensitive, wise, devoted, loyal, and he loved me deeper than I loved myself.

God joked with me, he called me Toots, he cuddled with me, he was physical in ways I wasn’t allowed to be as a gay man, and he comforted me when I was down. Yet when I needed him most—when the universe came at me with real-life stuff—like a meteor crashing to earth—God wasn’t there. And that’s because he was “never” there. I was there.

As a writer, I create characters all the time, and they’re powerful to me. They “exist!” I laugh with them, I cry with them. When I wrote The Children of the Night, there was one paragraph—one paragraph—that was so hard to get through it took me over three hours. And half of that was spent weeping—deeply sobbing because of the events taking place in that character’s life.

I love Timothy, Jeff, Julian, Sean, Tony, Pilgrim, Faithful, and all the other characters I’ve created over the years. I can tell you things about them that aren’t even in the books. I know how they feel about situations beyond their stories, the same way J.K. Rowling knew Professor Dumbledore was gay even though it was never mentioned.

Just like that, I loved the father I created. I see him reflected so often in my thoughts as the highest form of me. But he’s still a character that I created in the story of my life. I would never presume that the characters in the books I write are real. But they’re real to me.

In reality, I choose to “keep God,” knowing that he is a character—but one that I find beautifully attractive on so many levels. But he’s “my God” and nobody else’s.

Harry Potter is a story that has captivated millions around the world, and we all relate to him. We joke about him, we have memes, and we can tell the stories in our heads. He’s real to us, though he’s not real in the universe.

That’s what happened.

3

And like the bumper sticker says, ‘Blasphemy is a victimless crime’ smile009.gif

Varn Level 8 Dec 8, 2017

Must remember that one.

0

Lol.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text 'q:7263'.
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content read full disclaimer.
  • Agnostic.com is a non-profit community for atheists, agnostics, humanists, freethinkers, skeptics and others!