Agnostic.com
2 2

The monarch butterfly population has been in decline for several decades. The numbers today are less than 10% of what they were in 1960. There are two main reasons for this decline. First, is the use of herbicides and pesticides along with decreasing area of natural habitat. Like all butterflies, monarchs require a particular kind of plant on which to lay eggs. This is called a host plant, and for the monarch it is milkweed. If milkweed is not present, they have nowhere to lay eggs and therefore will not reproduce. They will not lay eggs on any plant other than milkweed. There are several types of milkweed. Two I am familiar with are common milkweed which is prevalent throughout the Midwest, and swamp milkweed, which I believe is more native to southern states. Either will will work for reproduction, as well as others. My belief is that it is better to stick with a native milkweed that is found in your geographic region. Although they are referred to as "weeds," both types flower, and neither is difficult to keep from spreading. I have grown milkweed for four years, and it continues to be confined to the areas in which I planted it.

The second reason for the decline is a direct result of the uniqueness of the monarch. It is the only North American butterfly that migrates. Each fall, monarchs travel from Canada and the US to an area in Mexico to "hibernate" in oyamel fir trees in a preserve outside of Angangueo, Michoacan, Mexico. In just the last 20 years, the forested area in which the monarchs over-winter has been reduced from 44 acres to less than 2 acres. The vast majority of the inhabitants of Angangueo live in poverty. At an altitude of 8400 feet, a source of heat is needed. In order to survive, many people illegally log the oyamel fir trees for themselves or to sell. Because of the extreme reduction of the forest acreage, fewer butterflies can be accommodated, thus contributing a further reason that monarchs are a threatened species.

What each of us can do locally is plant milkweed, establish a monarch population, harvest eggs and/or caterpillars and provide an environment for them to metamorphosize to adulthood to be released to increase your local monarch population. In a small way, we can also help reduce the poverty in Angangueo by purchasing "Mexi Rocks" through the Save Our Monarchs organization. As explained on the website, these rocks are painted by schoolchildren and sold to raise money for their own households.

So where do you get milkweed? Fortunately, many local nurseries have begun selling milkweed. If you would rather start your milkweed from seed or you are not sure if milkweed is sold locally, there are several websites from which you can purchase milkweed seeds.

What if there is no established monarch population in my area? I live in a city of 125,000 and although I live in an older neighborhood where almost everyone maintains flowerbeds, monarchs were few and far between four years ago when I started raising. There are websites which sell monarch eggs and/or caterpillars. The first two years that I did this, I purchased caterpillars. Starting in the third year, because of the milkweed that has been established, I began to see a sufficient number of wild butterflies to be able to harvest eggs and caterpillars from my own milkweed. Unfortunately, some states have laws preventing the shipment of insect larva, including monarchs into the state. If you live in one of those states, I am not sure what your options are. I hope we have members in those states who are aware of other options.

There are a tremendous number of websites about the plight of monarch butterflies. So as not to overwhelm you with information, I am only going to recommend two websites which I hope you will explore, and possibly to further research from there.

Saveourmonarchs.org In addition to a wealth of information about monarchs, you can also purchase milkweed and Mexi rocks from the site.
Rose Franklin has two websites: butterflybushes.com and monarchs-and-milkweed.com. This is where I purchased caterpillars for the first two years. She has also written a book "Fast Track to Butterfly Gardening" which I purchased and recommend. If you live near Spring Mills, PA, you may want to consider attending the open house this Memorial Day weekend.

In my next post, I will explain the stages of monarch metamorphosis and recommend containers for raising them. In the meantime, if you have experience raising butterflies and would like to add to the above, please do so.

MikeEC 7 Mar 12
Share
You must be a member of this group before commenting. Join Group

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

2 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

2

I will post several comments in the next few weeks about how to get started raising monarchs. It will be very helpful if each member would post the following information:

  1. Have you raised monarchs previously, or is this going to be a learn-how-to-do-it experience?

  2. What state do you live in? Monarchs arrive in Texas at least two months before they arrive in Minnesota. In Illinois where I live, we have monarchs from the end of June to the end of September. You should be able to find a local resource such as the University agriculture extension center that can provide information specific to your area.

3.Do you normally see very many monarchs in your area? If there are very few monarch butterflies, you will need to get your caterpillars elsewhere, which usually means purchasing them. Figuring out where to get them can be a challenge depending on which state you live in.

  1. If you are not raised monarchs previously it is not likely that you have been growing milkweed, so you'll need to get some. My first milkweed plants came from our local university extension center. They put on a seminar one spring which I attended, and they gave each attendee milkweed. There may be a similar program in your area. You can order milkweed seeds (which are easy to propagate) from websites such as saveourmonarchs.org. If you prefer to start from plants, check with your local nurseries. You must have an adequate supply of milkweed before attempting to raise monarchs from eggs or larva.

Next, I will post some information about monarch butterfly lifecycle, and then will share information about what is needed in order to raise them. If you plan to start out slowly, you can use containers such as clear plastic orange juice containers. To raise the numbers that I normally work with, the very best container is an aquarium. I used 10-gallon aquariums. I have found a couple at thrift shops. I checked Walmart.com recently, and they had one for less than $15. You don't even need a top because that will be made out of screening material such as window screen. More details later.

MikeEC Level 7 Mar 14, 2018

I have only raised and released butterflies once in my life but I absolutely loved it. I grew up in northern Ohio and common milkweed grew plentifully in ditches everywhere. Monarch butterflies were everywhere during the warm months.

I now live in the high desert in southern California and have never seen common milkweed here. I have seen swarms of migrating monarchs but it has become a much less common sight in my area.

I recently discovered a website that sells seeds for the type of milkweed native to my area and I am really looking forward to learning more about how to help increase the numbers of monarchs in my area. I am glad to have found your group.

2

I should plant some milkweed.

yep. You can order from saveourmonarchs.org

This looks like a good resource

[texasbutterflyranch.com]

Recent Visitors 12

Photos 104 More

Posted by TerriCitySulpher butterfly from caterpillar to pupa to adult butterfly.

Posted by TerriCitySulpher butterfly from caterpillar to pupa to adult butterfly.

Posted by TerriCitySulpher butterfly from caterpillar to pupa to adult butterfly.

Posted by TerriCitySulpher butterfly from caterpillar to pupa to adult butterfly.

Posted by LeafheadAsclepias sullivantii, the Sullivant's Prairie Milkweed. Taken at a way station in Middleton, WI

Posted by LeafheadCeropegia woodii Hoya carnosa Both plants bloom at night and attract lots of cool moths

Posted by LeafheadCeropegia woodii Hoya carnosa Both plants bloom at night and attract lots of cool moths

Posted by DAB456What kind is this? I think I know, but would like another opinion.

Posted by bigpawbulletsNot sure what these guys are. But suddenly we seem to be getting a few of them in the "Habitat":

Posted by bigpawbulletsSilly meme. But an attractive butterfly. Photoshopped or real?

Posted by MikeECI posted this earlier In the Gardeners group, but had actually intended to post it here. Those of you who are members of both groups get to see it twice ?

Posted by MikeECI posted this earlier In the Gardeners group, but had actually intended to post it here. Those of you who are members of both groups get to see it twice ?

Posted by LeafheadMy latest visitor to the feeder, a Hackberry Emperor

Posted by MikeECI managed to overwinter three Eastern black swallowtail chrysalises in my unheated garage and released them about a month ago.

Posted by MikeECI managed to overwinter three Eastern black swallowtail chrysalises in my unheated garage and released them about a month ago.

Posted by MikeECI managed to overwinter three Eastern black swallowtail chrysalises in my unheated garage and released them about a month ago.

  • Top tags#flowers #religion #god #Atheist #belief #reason #religious #hope #Present #survival #evidence #world #cats #agnostic #sleep #society #created #existence #video #dream #earth #death #Bible #holy #porn #money #babies #campaign #weed #Europe #Christians #atheism #secular #laws #advice #species #community #coffee #holiday #slavery #humans #rights #government #corruption #friends #relationship #freedom #justice #videos #memes ...

    Members 31Top

    Moderator

    Related Groups