Agnostic.com
6 2

I will post several comments in the next few weeks about how to get started raising monarchs. It will be very helpful if each member would post the following information:

  1. Have you raised monarchs previously, or is this going to be a learn-how-to-do-it experience?

  2. What state do you live in? Monarchs arrive in Texas at least two months before they arrive in Minnesota. In Illinois where I live, we have monarchs from the end of June to the end of September. You should be able to find a local resource such as the University agriculture extension center that can provide information specific to your area.

3.Do you normally see very many monarchs in your area? If there are very few monarch butterflies, you will need to get your caterpillars elsewhere, which usually means purchasing them. Figuring out where to get them can be a challenge depending on which state you live in.

  1. If you are not raised monarchs previously it is not likely that you have been growing milkweed, so you'll need to get some. My first milkweed plants came from our local university extension center. They put on a seminar one spring which I attended, and they gave each attendee milkweed. There may be a similar program in your area. You can order milkweed seeds (which are easy to propagate) from websites such as saveourmonarchs.org. If you prefer to start from plants, check with your local nurseries. You must have an adequate supply of milkweed before attempting to raise monarchs from eggs or larva.

Next, I will post some information about monarch butterfly lifecycle, and then will share information about what is needed in order to raise them. If you plan to start out slowly, you can use containers such as clear plastic orange juice containers. To raise the numbers that I normally work with, the very best container is an aquarium. I used 10-gallon aquariums. I have found a couple at thrift shops. I checked Walmart.com recently, and they had one for less than $15. You don't even need a top because that will be made out of screening material such as window screen. More details later.

MikeEC 7 Mar 14
Share
You must be a member of this group before commenting. Join Group

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

6 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0
  1. Have you raised monarchs previously, or is this going to be a learn-how-to-do-it experience?

No, I have not. I'll be reading, watching, and learning.

  1. What state do you live in?

Covington, Louisiana. About 43 miles directly north of New Orleans. We are always about 10 degrees cooler than New Orleans.

3.Do you normally see very many monarchs in your area?

Not that I recall.

BlueWave Level 8 Mar 29, 2018
1

Hi! I live in Florida and started a butterfly garden about three years ago by building a trellis for vines and planting milkweeds and flowers for nectar. We happen to have an old parrot cage on our screened in back porch and I covered it with tulle and turned it into my "caterpillar house". I have raised five types of butterflies by bringing caterpillars on their host plants into the caterpillar house where they could grow and turn into pupas and then into butterflies, after which they are released.

TerriCity Level 7 Mar 27, 2018

Here are some pictures of monarchs, milkweed (tropical) and pupa's and some caterpillars in the "J" position just before beginning to pupate. We get monarch's here almost year round.

Here is a black swallowtail. The host plants for them are anise or dill and parsley.

One of the few sulphur butterflies I was able to raise. host plants are cassia or senna.

1
  1. I suppose I have raised them indirectly, as I used to allow wild milkweed to grow in my yard, i.e. I wouldn't mow it down. I also encouraged my ex not to mow over it. When I get my own home (again), I plan on growing lots of milkweed, and maybe some Northern Blazing Star if it will grow where I end up. The last time I saw lots of monarchs was at Kennebunk Plains in Maine, but that's been over thirteen years ago. I'll try to dig out my photos, as the Northern Blazing Star at Kennebunk Plains is more purple than pink. When I was there, the plants were covered in monarchs. 🙂 [nature.org]

  2. Vermont. I think there's a better map available somewhere. When I have more time, I'll to through my links. Here's an updating map that tracks monarch migration. [learner.org]

  3. Now that I'm living in a city, I haven't seen as many. My car died, so I don't often get out. I think I saw two or three last year. However, I hadn't seen very many the last few years at my old home, and it was in a rural area.

Thank you for the useful links. The Plains conservation effort in Maine looks very similar to the Prairie conservation effort that is ongoing in Illinois. I love the map of the migration of monarchs! I have seen "generic maps" but never one that actually tracks live in a particular year. I will make sure that I check it at least weekly.

I also live in a city, in the "older" section which has no shortage of beautiful flowering plants and flowers. Four years ago, when I started raising monarchs, there were very few visiting our flowerbeds. The reason is that there was no milkweed. Once I planted milkweed, I still had to purchase monarch larva to get a population started, but at the beginning of the third "monarch season" I began to see more and more monarchs in the wild, and have been able to continue my monarch raising activities without having to purchase larva.

Experts theorize that among many other aspects of their genetic makeup, there is a navigational component that directs future generations to the geographic area in which there ancestor metamorphosized. From my limited experience, that appears to be true.

You will not see any monarchs at all until at least July. In one of my future posts, I will provide links to where you can purchase larva to get started. In the meantime, I will also post instructions for creating your "raising environment" and where to get the all-important milkweed.

@PappyOnWings Thanks. I won't be buying any larvae, at least not until I can move into my own home, and partially because I'm a pauper. I spent years painstakingly pulling out non-natives, and allowing goldenrods, New England aster, Joe-Pye weed and other native plants to flourish at my old home. My ex sold it to people who wasted no time mowing down everything, even after I explained why I had encouraged certain plants and yanked others. It was heartbreaking.

If I can muster the energy, I'll see if any of the community gardens in town will dedicate a plot as a pollinator garden. One local business planted natives, but I noticed the last time I went by that it was back to non-natives. I suppose enough people complained about their native garden looking like "weeds". I can just collect seeds here from wild plants.

I don't ever expect to see monarchs until long after the snow has melted. We still have snow pack here in Vermont. 🙂

@ailurophile Here is a suggestion that I have never seen on any other website, but which I have done myself. I hope it works for you. First of all, make sure you have milkweed. You can get one packet of seeds free from saveourmonarchs.org, and you can plant the seeds in pots.

My suggestion to get free caterpillars is to wait until "monarch season" starts, then begin to visit local nurseries that grow milkweed. Inspect the milkweed to find larva (usually very small ones) and ask if you can have them. Usually, they are happy to let you have the caterpillars because left on the milkweed they will consume it, therefore rendering it not-fit-to-sell. I have also gotten black Eastern swallowtail caterpillars this way, by picking them off parsley plants and taking them home.

2
  1. I have some knowledge of how one might proceed. I contemplated raising several
    species a good many years ago, Monarchs included. I am most willing and eager
    to learn more. I have had the penchant for creating a Lepidopterary in the past, I
    would like to pursue that dream again.
  2. Central Kentucky, Lexington specifically.
  3. I still see them from time to time, though I have not gone afield to observe in
    many years.
  4. The other 3 😉 Yes. You are correct I do not have any Milkweed at this time. That
    will will be job one naturally.
CapriKious Level 7 Mar 18, 2018

Please contribute your thoughts anytime. Another species I really enjoy raising is black swallowtail. The swallowtail chrysalis looks nothing like the monarch chrysalis. It is his brown and blends in very well with tree bark. I have three or four of them over-wintering in my garage. It is the first time I have done this, and I am hoping I did everything correctly.

@PappyOnWings It would seem we have similar tastes in the flutterbys we like. What do the Swallowtail caterpillars feed on again? I knew, but have forgotten.

@CapriKious Several different herbs, as well as carrot tops, are host plants for swallowtails. I have fennel in my plant beds and set potted parsley around the yard. I had no trouble collecting eggs last summer. Their eggs are much easier to recognize then monarch eggs.

2

Never raised them . I live in norteastern nm. Very few monarchs around here but the wildlife refuge does counts. There is usually one milkweed plant growing by my house. I don't know how many you need

btroje Level 9 Mar 15, 2018
2

I’m in Texas near Houston. I don’t see nearly as many as I used to here.

Once you have milkweed, it will take a couple of years to establish a monarch population.@Plainjane, who also lives in Texas, has already seen a monarch. You have a much longer "monarch season" than most of the rest of us, but to get started raising them, you may have to purchase caterpillars this year and next year both. Because of your location, it may be much easier to find local suppliers than it is for those of us living further north.

Write Comment

Recent Visitors 13

Photos 104 More

Posted by TerriCitySulpher butterfly from caterpillar to pupa to adult butterfly.

Posted by TerriCitySulpher butterfly from caterpillar to pupa to adult butterfly.

Posted by TerriCitySulpher butterfly from caterpillar to pupa to adult butterfly.

Posted by TerriCitySulpher butterfly from caterpillar to pupa to adult butterfly.

Posted by LeafheadAsclepias sullivantii, the Sullivant's Prairie Milkweed. Taken at a way station in Middleton, WI

Posted by LeafheadCeropegia woodii Hoya carnosa Both plants bloom at night and attract lots of cool moths

Posted by LeafheadCeropegia woodii Hoya carnosa Both plants bloom at night and attract lots of cool moths

Posted by DAB456What kind is this? I think I know, but would like another opinion.

Posted by bigpawbulletsNot sure what these guys are. But suddenly we seem to be getting a few of them in the "Habitat":

Posted by bigpawbulletsSilly meme. But an attractive butterfly. Photoshopped or real?

Posted by MikeECI posted this earlier In the Gardeners group, but had actually intended to post it here. Those of you who are members of both groups get to see it twice ?

Posted by MikeECI posted this earlier In the Gardeners group, but had actually intended to post it here. Those of you who are members of both groups get to see it twice ?

Posted by LeafheadMy latest visitor to the feeder, a Hackberry Emperor

Posted by MikeECI managed to overwinter three Eastern black swallowtail chrysalises in my unheated garage and released them about a month ago.

Posted by MikeECI managed to overwinter three Eastern black swallowtail chrysalises in my unheated garage and released them about a month ago.

Posted by MikeECI managed to overwinter three Eastern black swallowtail chrysalises in my unheated garage and released them about a month ago.

  • Top tags#flowers #religion #god #Atheist #belief #reason #religious #hope #Present #survival #evidence #world #cats #agnostic #society #sleep #existence #created #video #dream #earth #Bible #death #holy #porn #money #babies #campaign #Europe #weed #Christians #secular #atheism #laws #advice #species #community #coffee #holiday #slavery #humans #corruption #rights #government #relationship #friends #videos #freedom #justice #memes ...

    Members 31Top

    Moderator