Agnostic.com
4 1

Review of the book: "Short History of Atheism", by Gavin Hyman

The author is a theologian and this book is intended for theologians only. Whoever expects a "short history of atheism" - like me - will be disappointed.

The core thesis of the book is already at the beginning (basically the rest of the book is a detailed analysis of this thesis):

"The advent of modernity brought with it a transformed conception of God, a distinctively 'modern' theism. When God is understood to be an object of thought, then God is created in the image of humanity. God comes to be conceived in human terms, his transcendence is domesticated and, in some instances at least, God increasingly takes on the characteristics of a 'big person'. In effect, God becomes a projection of the human subject."

Atheism is a thoroughly modern phenomenon, and moreover it is a kind of "collateral damage" of a development of the understanding of God, because at the beginning of modernity God was more and more humanized, the medieval idea of God as ultimate subject - to which man and the whole world stood opposite as "objects", is reversed: now humans understand themselves more and more as subjects and masters and stand opposite the world as such, which leads to God also becoming an object, a special, elevated object, but an object nevertheless . It is no surprise when people take a closer look at this object "God" and discover that it has human traits, which is not surprising, since this anthropomorphized God is the result of objectification brought about by the human mind.

From there it is only a small and logical step to the conclusion that this God is nothing more than a fiction produced by human minds. And atheism becomes all but inevitable.

What disturbed me about the book was that the author argues theologically only. When he deals with the 20th century (in the last chapter), for instance, he quotes (at length !) other theologians. The atheists are only briefly mentioned. From the author's point of view they cannot be taken seriously anyway. Intellectually the music plays on the side of theology (and philosophy), where the modern understanding of God is being debated, and modern atheism is only a by-product of this (modern!) understanding of God - which of course the stupid atheists do not understand, because they lack the intellectual depth and horizon (which, if one looks at the so-called "new atheists" around Richard Dawkins, is a quite correct assessment).

My conclusion: whoever is theologically educated and loves the "big picture" of the history of ideas will get his money's worth in this book. If, on the other hand, you are looking for a short history of atheism, you better buy "Atheism. A very short introduction" by Julian Baggini

Matias 8 June 23
Share
You must be a member of this group before commenting. Join Group

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

4 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

Thanks, im seeing & hearing a new push for
human conciousness as an underpinning for
and against religions. His idea that mankind
has"left god behind" / and the "new"- give
god control of your conciousness sound
like faces of the same coin !!! "Humanity is inherently bad and needs outside controls"
¤i see both as a BIG waste of human POTENTIAL ¤

BBJong Level 7 July 21, 2019
0

Ok, point taken. Thx

IamNobody Level 8 June 24, 2019
0

Possibly the greatest thought in opposition to the external God is William Blake's concept of God being internal, in man's imagination:

I rest not from my great task!
To open the Eternal Worlds, to open the immortal Eyes
Of Man inwards into the Worlds of Thought: into Eternity
Ever expanding in the Bosom of God, the Human Imagination.

  • Jerusalem, Plate 5, Lines 17b - 20.

For a very critical assessment of Blake's religious ideas, I recommend John Vervaeke's YT video here:

brentan Level 8 June 23, 2019
0

Perspective - point of view . The answer was chosen before any research was anticipated .

Cast1es Level 9 June 23, 2019
Write Comment

Recent Visitors 17

Photos 31 More

Posted by Julie808We of Little Faith I Stopped Pretending to Believe (and Maybe You Should Too) By Kate Cohen.

Posted by dfrossI enjoyed "The Dictionary of Lost Words", a historical fiction about the creating of the Oxford-English Dictionary and the fight for women's suffrage in the UK.

Posted by ReignmondA highly biased selection.

Posted by ReignmondI read this back in 2018. Absolutely loved it. It is an oddly small sized book, so it is good to travel with. [amazon.com]

Posted by ReignmondI read this back in 2018. Absolutely loved it. It is an oddly small sized book, so it is good to travel with. [amazon.com]

Posted by ReignmondA short Sci-Fi that is quite good even though it will only take about an hour to read. It is also kinda cheap. [amazon.com]

Posted by ReignmondLooking again at this book reminds me that I wanted to re-listen to it again.

Posted by ReignmondThis freebie ebook from Gutenberg Press and by the Master Sci-Fi writer Philip.

Posted by ReignmondAt Home: a short history of private life by Bill Bryson. An enjoyable book about everyday things we don't even think about. [amazon.com]

Posted by ReignmondAt Home: a short history of private life by Bill Bryson. An enjoyable book about everyday things we don't even think about. [amazon.com]

Posted by ReignmondJust finished Bomber Mafia written by my genetic 4th cousin on both of our Fathers' side.

Posted by ReignmondI read this back in about 1983.

Posted by ReignmondVery good. I have noticed that 12 step programs are ineffective. [goodreads.com]

Posted by ReignmondActually read this some time ago (46 years) while trying to figure out why I simply could not believe in Jesus or God or anything else I was being told by Bible Thumpers.

Posted by ReignmondThis is one of my very most favorite books.

Posted by Julie808I'm currently reading "The Power Worshippers" by Katherine Stewart. Is anyone else reading this?

  • Top tags#book #books #world #god #novels #religion #hope #religious #DonaldTrump #Christian #authors #writers #atheism #friends #truth #Jesus #scifi #Bible #Atheist #humanity #children #hell #christianity #movies #philosophy #evolution #death #earth #humans #violence #NewYork #murder #Russian #agnostic #media #insane #grace #divine #parents #believer #fantasy #testament #politicians #USA #devil #florida #Noah #sleep #community #ghosts ...

    Members 145Top

    Moderator