7 2

Don’t End a Sentence with a Preposition—Where Did This Myth Come From?

I love this kind of history. Sad this kind of idiocy has affected 200+ years of authorship.

[data.grammarbook.com]

Jacar 8 Aug 7
You must be a member of this group before commenting. Join Group

Post a comment Reply Add Photo

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

7 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

People often claim that Winston Churchill pooh-poohed the rule, saying something like, "That is a piece of arrant pedantry up with which I shall not put." This story, like the God story, comes in countless variations with no evidence.

alfresco Level 4 Aug 8, 2018
0

Steven Pinker's vids about language are great::: This is a wonderfully full lecture:::

Jacar Level 8 Aug 7, 2018
0

The article is wonderfully detailed.

Jacar Level 8 Aug 7, 2018
2

It comes from a crazy idea that Latin was perfect and that English should behave more like Latin in order to be correct. In reality though, prepositions at the end of sentences in English are either parts of phrasal verbs (where two or more words are used to make one verb, as in "blow up" = explode), or they occur at the end of relative clauses and govern an earlier item (The people I was staying with), so the preposition still feels as if it comes before the thing it governs, but it's been moved out of position (I stayed with some people) - there is still an unspoken trace of "people" following the preposition.

Ack! Latin is perfect, you heathen! 😉

1

What the hell is a preposition ???

Michael67 Level 6 Aug 7, 2018

You talkin to me?

0

@Jacar -- LOL

That old rigidity again. ----------------> Whence came this myth?

2

Yep I’ve been shutting fools down for this since middle school. It usually functions as an adverb at the end of a sentence. It’s quite awkward to avoid sometimes and even if it were true, as a part time grammar Nazi, (full time lover) I would rather sound colloquial than pretentious.

Wurlitzer Level 8 Aug 7, 2018
Write Comment