Agnostic.com
3 5

[arstechnica.com]

A 43,900-year-old cave painting is the oldest story ever recorded

Archaeologists say it might also contain the oldest known religious images.

moosepucky 7 Dec 29
Share
You must be a member of this group before commenting. Join Group

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

3 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

Brilliant post. We know hunter/gatherers hunted aurochs in what is now Salisbury Plain in south of England around 10,000 years ago.

It would make sense that there is a ceremonial reason for depicting these scenes as the hunting season begins.

Geoffrey51 Level 8 Dec 29, 2019
0

You conjecture unfortunately cannot be substantiated factually. It makes sense, but many mistakes were made early in the field when enthusiastic archaeologists labeled the purpose as spiritual/ religious, only to later find the purpose was much more benign. Error on the side of caution is a good axiom to follow.

t1nick Level 8 Dec 29, 2019
3

When I was an archaeologist (1975-1982), the bane of our field was when some researcher attempted to ascribe religious attributes and meanings to some new discovery or artifact. It was quite common in the first millennia of the field of archaeology for people to describe any previously unknown object that was not immediately obvious as religious or serving a religious purpose.

New Archaeology practices required us to describe the artifact, but not attempt to give it an unprovable religious function. We could suggest potential uses based on the physical attributes of the object, but not ascribe subjective attributes.

t1nick Level 8 Dec 29, 2019

@t1nick

I have a feeling that early societies attributed what they could not understand to the supernatural. That way the unknown was not as frightening. "Oh the big boogie woogie did it again"

Attributing a solar eclipse to some "greater mystic power" was easier on the mind than worrying about "omg we're all gonna die"

I'm no archeologist but as a lay person this makes more sense than institutionalized religion which came later to give power to those with balls enough to stand up and profess they knew what was going on.

Recent Visitors 26

Photos 169 More

Posted by PiratefishSeasons greetings, you heathens.

Posted by SurfpirateA photographic collection of pagan costumes associated with the winter solstice. [dangerousminds.net]

Posted by MoonTigerIIAncient Evenings Fun!

Posted by AnonySchmoose[cell.

Posted by AnonySchmoose[cell.

Posted by AnonySchmoose[cell.

Posted by EyesThatSmileThis sculptor is amazing. [boredpanda.com]

Posted by DruviusWell preserved 500 year old ship found at bottom of Baltic Sea. Way cool find, hope we have the means to properly investigate it. [sciencealert.com]

Posted by qpr81there's a small island in front of the temple site and they found artifacts even there.

Posted by qpr81there's a small island in front of the temple site and they found artifacts even there.

Posted by qpr81there's a small island in front of the temple site and they found artifacts even there.

Posted by qpr81the hole in this image -according to the guide- was a window to let the sun rays hit a certain spot announcing the summer/winter etc.

Posted by qpr81Trajan's column in Rome. Shame they put a pope on top of it. Even though this is a monument raised over a genocide it's still something worth seeing.

Posted by qpr81Trajan's column in Rome. Shame they put a pope on top of it. Even though this is a monument raised over a genocide it's still something worth seeing.

Posted by qpr81Trajan's column in Rome. Shame they put a pope on top of it. Even though this is a monument raised over a genocide it's still something worth seeing.

Posted by qpr81Ħaġar Qim temple in Malta. Stunning even if a bit of walk...

  • Top tags#video #ancient #world #humans #god #book #evidence #religion #religious #discovery #animals #hope #culture #kids #society #Europe #China #created #Atheist #Present #DNA #friends #death #wife #ancestors #reason #museum #truth #USA #parents #church #dogs #university #movies #burial #hell #Bible #Christian #cats #community #earth #money #children #Jesus #species #archeology #evolution #vote #relationship #beliefs ...

    Members 5Top

    Moderator