Agnostic.com
2 1

Anyone else ever take secret pleasure in someone else's weight loss struggles?

I was pretty much a chubby/fat child and became for the most part a fat/obese adult. There were occasions when I lost substantial amounts of weight but it always crept back when I "finished" dieting.

Throughout the years, although my father was never openly ugly toward me about my weight, I had no problem, by the time I was an adult, picking up on what his opinion was of people who were fat. He was one of those people who never dieted in his youth or adult life. He had no reason to, he worked fairly physical jobs and apparently had a metabolism that I did not inherit from him. He was lean at around 5'10" and maybe 150 -160 pound and never appeared to work at it.

It was not hard to discern that he believed that people who were overweight lacked certain traits, like discipline, will power or self-control. He also thought that all a fat person needed to do to not be fat was to buckle down and lose the extra pounds. This is not an uncommon belief among people who have never had to work to maintain a "normal" weight, IMO. They may not be blatant about it, although some certainly are but you pick up the subtle signals.

Unfortunately (for them) time catches up with some of them. After retiring by dad's penchant for living on bologna sandwiches, potato chips and beer combined with less activity and age resulted in him packing on pounds that he had never had before. He had a heart attack and bypass surgery but even though he ate a bit better after that he still gained some, reaching maybe 220 pounds although his doctor was telling him to lose.

While it bothered me that he had gained weight and that his health was at risk because of it, I found myself rather amused and actually getting a bit of twisted enjoyment out of the situation. He would complain about his inability to lose weight while making no real effort to deprive himself of anything. He would look incessantly for a "magic pill" that would make weight just go away.

I attempted to advise him of ways to go about dropping pounds but to no avail. Of course the beer was a significant factor but he insisted in equating the "glass or two of wine" that the doctor said was not bad for his health, to an unknown number of beers a day. His years of not struggling to maintain a good weight really set him up to fail. He could not understand why just saying he was going to lose did not fix the problem.

Eventually, it all caught up with him, the extra weight on top of close to 50 years of smoking (he did quit at around 66) CHF, emphysema, chronic Afib and alcoholism took him down at 81 years old. Could look at it as a pretty long life for someone who didn't put a lot of effort into healthy living. For a time, after he died, I felt rather guilty that I had taken some pleasure in his struggles with weight but I don't any longer. It was what it was, a little karma.

DotLewis 7 Aug 21
Share
You must be a member of this group before commenting. Join Group

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

2 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

Oh yes... an ex's daughter was very clear about her thoughts on weight when she was an active high school dancer-gymnast. Now, 15-years and several marriages and children (for her) later, I've lost 80# and she's gained probably as much, reversing our appearances, with various reasons for why it isn't her fault (never said it was). Yep, a little karma. So far, she hasn't made the connection that eating crappy food will just do that to you when you become an adult who isn't active all day.

mtnhome Level 7 Aug 21, 2018
0

I think that is very understandable. People who are naturally thin have no understanding of weight problems in my experience, and little sympathy for people who struggle with their weight. We would have to be incredibly virtuous not to take just a little bit of pleasure in their failures!

CeliaVL Level 7 Aug 21, 2018

Recent Visitors 9

Photos 99 More

Posted by OldMetalHeadI hit a new weight milestone this week. Still trying for the six-pack.

Posted by OldMetalHeadThe hardest part for me is not falling back into old bad habits after meeting goals.

Posted by OldMetalHeadThe hardest part for me is not falling back into old bad habits after meeting goals.

Posted by OldMetalHeadThe hardest part for me is not falling back into old bad habits after meeting goals.

Posted by OldMetalHeadThe hardest part for me is not falling back into old bad habits after meeting goals.

Posted by JonnaBononnaI had finally gotten back on track after gaining back most of the weight I lost a couple of years ago.

Posted by JurneeI have to say, as an overweight karate instructor, this is the one patch that I was ok with never getting.

Posted by DotLewis13 March 2020 - Diet Diary - Holding steady, up a little, down a little.

Posted by DotLewis13 March 2020 - Diet Diary - Holding steady, up a little, down a little.

Posted by DotLewis7 March 2020 - Diet Diary - Been quiet around here lately. I've not been on vacation, just keeping a low profile and trying to stay on top of things. Are those things incompatible?

Posted by DotLewis26 Sept.

Posted by MyMrsFifiAte my tiny meal...... Still hungry.... Waiting for snack time like this......

Posted by DotLewisWell, that's annoying! Twice I "shared" this post from Gardeners group to here and neither time did it appear.

Posted by DotLewisWell, that's annoying! Twice I "shared" this post from Gardeners group to here and neither time did it appear.

Posted by DotLewisTrade wars?

Posted by DotLewisTrade wars?

  • Top tags#Diet #hope #Exercise #dogs #weather #friends #sleep #coffee #Friday #god #reason #book #video #limit #Shopping #church #world #religious #Atheist #kids #rain #atheism #religion #hell #parents #animals #money #humans #apple #cats #holiday #Christmas #death #children #agnostic #Christian #relationship #cancer #chinese #fear #mother #anxiety #vote #beliefs #truth #Bible #evidence #saved #weed #oil ...

    Members 255Top

    Moderators