Agnostic.com
3 1

My understanding of the law regarding taking another life is very confused. It was my understanding causing death is manslaughter. If it is premeditated its murder. Premeditated murder is a nonesense as murder is already premeditated by definition.
So this guy just gets found not guilty of murder but guilty of manslaughter. He reckons she may be alive, she ran away. He will not get parole until he reveals where the body is.
Seems a lot of doubt and premedotated to me so wtf is going on with a manslaughter conviction? Also, thought it was either Either, prosecution had to choose what to proceed with; manslaughter or murder ie can't do both.

Any (ex) copper, lawyer types here who can explain wtf the law is saying here?

powder 8 Sep 9
Share
You must be a member of this group before commenting. Join Group

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

3 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

If you were at a bar and some guy made you so angry you shoved him and he tripped and hit his head and died, then the difference between manslaughter and first degree murder would feel very real very quickly I suspect.

David1955 Level 8 Sep 9, 2019
0

I am confused too. What are you referring to?

0

Technically, as I understand, a consideration has to be made between ‘mens rea’ (intention) and ‘actus reus’ (guilty act). Was the criminality in mind (premeditated i. e. planned and considered ), or a spur of the moment act.

In the absence of the victims's body prosectutory authoritues tend to pursue the manslaughter avenue... I find that reading strange... I guess they lure the perpetrator into a guilty plea for manslaughter.

@PontifexMarximus That could be right. The Reid Technique could probably make that happen under the circumstance.

Recent Visitors 8

Photos 150 More

Posted by 1patriotthey are creating a 15 Cities all along this coast in Australia

Posted by 1patriotthunder writes: I remember early in the pandemic when there was a protest outside the hospital (Toronto Canada).

Posted by vocaloldfart Is this the way of the future?

Posted by vocaloldfartIf you think times were tough under the LNP Mafiosa in the previous years, Give Dutton the disastrous destroyer the vote in the next election, and look foreward to worse to come.

Posted by vocaloldfartMichael Pascoe: And the award for the worst Liberal leader goes to… ?

Posted by vocaloldfartDingoes elevated to 'almost-human' status in pre-colonial Australia .

Posted by vocaloldfartVanadium batteries’ sustainable energy hailed as key to solar revolution Vanadium could be the answer to using solar and wind round the clock, silencing critics who say they’re useless when the...

Posted by FrayedBearThis amused me. How about you? "Don’t worry about the world coming to an end today. It is already tomorrow in Australia." Charles Shulz

Posted by FrayedBearNine chairman, and former Australian Treasurer, Peter Costello is now promoting war with China after making $millions lobbying for defence companies BY SHANE DOWLING ON MARCH 12, 2023

Posted by FrayedBearIt has taken since 1986 for the Australian Human Rights Commission to release papers & a suggested draft for incorporation into Australian law to protect all citizens.

Posted by FrayedBearIt has taken since 1986 for the Australian Human Rights Commission to release papers & a suggested draft for incorporation into Australian law to protect all citizens.

Posted by FrayedBearIt has taken since 1986 for the Australian Human Rights Commission to release papers & a suggested draft for incorporation into Australian law to protect all citizens.

Posted by FrayedBearIt has taken since 1986 for the Australian Human Rights Commission to release papers & a suggested draft for incorporation into Australian law to protect all citizens.

Posted by FrayedBearWhat a con - mRNA vaccinations?

Posted by FrayedBearWhy is the Murdoch media not widely reporting this apparent scandal that should prevent the NSW Premier being re-elected for a further 4 years?

Posted by vocaloldfartsign of the times

  • Top tags#Australia #government #video #world #god #religious #hope #friends #laws #politicians #religion #minister #federal #money #media #reason #DonaldTrump #children #liberal #politics #rights #community #Police #Atheist #military #evidence #death #Christian #Jesus #China #hell #church #atheism #policy #USA #parents #corruption #youtube #vote #book #religions #truth #dogs #kids #justice #faith #agnostic #trolls #movies #population ...

    Members 428Top

    Moderator