Agnostic.com
11 6

Okay, I would really appreciate some help. Could you give me some thought provoking questions for a religiously addled, child's mind? Questions that don't point directly at the fallacy of religion, but hint at it and cause the person to draw their own conclusions. It's for clever kids, but dumbed down due to religion, so take 'er easy.

THANK YOU!

Donotbelieve 9 May 19
Share
You must be a member of this group before commenting. Join Group

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

11 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

I always try to teach the science and ask them to come to me with questions.

Sporktime Level 4 May 25, 2018
0

Just about any biblical story makes no sense if taken as a fact (and not a parable), I think you could take your pick.

sabihondo Level 3 May 25, 2018
0

Try asking: Can God do anything? Yes. Ok

Can God make anything? Yes. Ok

Can God make a stone? Yes. Ok

Can God make a rock? Yes. Ok

Can God make a boulder? Yes. Ok

Can God make a mountain? Yes. Ok

Can God make a mountain so big that he himself couldn’t move it? Yes. Ok

If God can do anything can’t he move the mountain he just made? So him God? Hmmm

2

Easy ones I gave my 6 year old son.

Who is God?
What is God?
What does God look like?
What are angels?
What are demons?
Who created the angels and demons?

then follow up with:
How do you know?
How do they know?
First prove they exist, then we can try to figure out how they were created.

A simple line of questioning like this got my son to see the point.

4

Ask what you should do if god told you to sacrifice one of your children.

Okay, seriously. My son and I had multiple conversations and I did not convince him. I asked everytthing and nothing cracked his faith, but questioning the morality of various churches and ministers and pointing out the hypocrisy swayed his views.

He's still religious, but not hypocritical or judgmental. He doesn't preach or impose his beliefs on others. He's one of those rare liberal christians with a conscience. I'll call that a win.

JimG Level 8 May 19, 2018
2

Perhaps the story of noah,s ark.there is so much of it that makes no sense. How could so few people collect and take care of so many animals. How could they feed them. How could they keep them from killing each other. If evolution isn't true they had to collect every type of every species.how did they catch every type of bird on every continent. How could they build a boat that big with the same few people. How did they redistribute those animals. How did the plants of the world survive. There is so much more that's wrong with that story alone. How I handle that problem is to talk to them about evolution and answer questions with the factual truth. Time will do the rest. Either way mine decide at least they have time to decide for themselves and I hope the memories I left with them teach reason and science even if they ultimately believe in a god. That would be fine with me. Lots of people do

4

Get them into astronomy or take the to a natural history museum

WallyWorld Level 5 May 19, 2018
2

What age is the child? This is an important consideration.
However, it is very easy to draw an analogy to Father Christmas, which is a lovely myth for young children to be fooled with - but which they eventually work out for themselves is just something which brings joy to youngsters, and then to question whether religious belief is not also perhaps a myth.

Petter Level 9 May 19, 2018
2

Not sure if you are familiar with the site, but atheist republic has a good list of books for skeptical children. Some of them will probably have stuff you can use in conversations.

[atheistrepublic.com]

zeuser Level 9 May 19, 2018
0

What age?

skado Level 9 May 19, 2018

@Donotbelieve
I have never raised children so I am probably a poor source of advice but an angle I saw in a book once was to make a tradition of putting on family plays around holidays and simply speak of the characters as characters rather than persons, to plant the seed of thought that these figures are metaphorical representations of universal human psychology; not actual beings. For instance, instead of saying God, always (not just at holidays) remember to say “the God character”, or the Santa character, or the Easter Bunny character. A consistent effort at framing such perspectives can help set assumptions that arise later in life. An education in art, symbolism, poetry, metaphor, etc. helps establish an alternative to literalism.

1

How about an examination of the mythical stories about Santa Claus, the Easter Bunny, the Tooth Fairy, and the Great Pumpkin?

Heraclitus Level 8 May 19, 2018
Write Comment

Recent Visitors 36

Photos 27 More

Posted by Observer-EffectAlright . . . this is a harsh picture to look at, but does it show nudity?

Posted by FrostyJimDon't believe what you think you saw...

Posted by SunishineI don't give off visible light, so...

Posted by SunishineEssential oils crisis

Posted by SunishineDon't step in that!

Posted by SunishineWho built it?

Posted by SunishineO-o-o-o-o-o-o!

Posted by SunishineSkeptic Baby

Posted by UmbralAnyone subscribe?

Posted by UmbralClimate Deniers Are More Likely to Hate Democracy If you care strongly about climate change, you’re most likely to be someone passionate about democracy.

Posted by UmbralThis one is gouda.

Posted by JeffBHere is a guild to help your health.

Posted by UmbralSo sad and needless.

Posted by CuriousCreatureNational Society of Skeptics

Posted by SunishineNo, no, please continue. ..

Posted by JimGSomething you can use when necessary.

  • Top tags#video #skeptics #religion #god #church #Skeptic #world #prayer #separation #agnostic #conspiracy #theories #religious #skeptical #bullshit #relationship #reason #scientific #money #pseudoscience #media #atheism #skepticism #evidence #religions #movies #Jesus #CriticalThinking #flood #JamesRandi #brainwashed #ancient #hope #philosophy #mother #HappyNewYear #Atheist #Christian #LMAO #nudity #superstitions #politics #Socialmedia #DonaldTrump #Humanist #MikePence #books #book #Bible #ClimateChange ...

    Members 125Top

    Moderator