Agnostic.com

3 1

I really wonder if "god" always meant what it meant today. For example Spanish respirar»to breath is made of re and spirar which sounds like spirit which is often a symbol for "god". Also dead people don't breath. In Japanese kami means both spirit and god. It's said "god" is in the heavens. ... so does that mean that so called god is nothing else then oxygen? And maybe everything else about it is misstranslation. Just a thought.

dante92 4 July 20
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

3 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

I have no objection to the use of the word "god" as a metaphorical personification of the collective forces of nature, and I suspect that is not far from the original usage. I suspect, likewise, "heaven" is symbolic of the upward direction. Upward relative to the human body is the head, or mind. Upward relative to values is the lofty ones. Upward relative to transcending suffering is that space above suffering. Etc., etc.

skado Level 9 July 21, 2020

Also, I think there is an etymological connection between the word "god" and the word "good".

0

No doubt the concept has morphed through time and civilizations. I forget how many ‘gods’ the Romans had.. Around me, it’s been narrowed down to 2 or 3 😉

‘gods’ remain the evidence of human frailty and fears. Sadly, those still exist ~

Varn Level 8 July 21, 2020
1

Yes there are quite complex theological debates about this, especially about the original Hebrew meaning of the word, which had similar origins to the Spanish. If you are interested they are fairly easy to research on the web. But I do not think you learn anything of value from it about religion, only about language and how it evolves and get altered over time.

So much of religion may well be caused by mistranslation, bad memories and copying. Imagine that someone once told a story, about how a man and his family survived a flood by building a boat. And how they were wise enough to put a couple each of all their 'domestic' animals in as well. There would not be many, perhaps just a couple of goats and two sheep, not even perhaps in those days chickens. Then what happens if one night a story teller forgets to put in the word domestic ?

Perfume, scent, essence and spirit, also have a similar complex and ramified linkage in their origins. Don't forget for example that spirit has at least three meanings, soul, vigour and the intoxicating part of drink. Which was of course the original meaning of biblical 'wine' both the natural, and the sacramental type. While many people think that the Islamic ban on alcohol may be a mistake, and that the ban on 'wine' may only have originally been intended only for Christian sacramental wine. Many saints bodies were said to give off sweet perfume when they died, because your scent was literally once believed to be part of the soul, therefore most dead bodies smell of sin, therefore bad, while saints smell good, and the fact that you smell at all proves there is a soul.

You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:517214
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.