By Sophia Vento - 09/14/24

Republicans are reprising efforts to legally challenge election law in three key battleground states that could help decide who wins in November.

Michigan, North Carolina and Nevada are targets of the blitz, led by the Republican National Committee alongside state parties who are questioning election integrity when it comes to absentee ballots, the use of digital voter cards and whether noncitizens are being allowed to vote.

All three states were narrowly won in 2020 with Trump winning North Carolina by 1.3 percent and President Biden taking Michigan by 3 points and Nevada by 7 points and are considered toss ups in 2024, according to DDHQ averages.

Trump notoriously challenged his 2020 overall election loss, and the lawsuits filed this week also come as election deniers see their power solidified on the state level, worrying legal observers who say that gives a glimpse into what potential chaos might loom in 2024.

Here’s everything you need to know about the election-related cases in the battlegrounds.

Absentee ballots in Michigan

The Michigan lawsuit, filed on Thursday, argues Michigan Secretary of State Jocelyn Benson failed to require the “proper” verification of absentee ballots through her office’s election guidance, which Republicans say omits certain requirements.

The RNC and Michigan Republican Party have asked a Michigan court to reject absentee ballots without a written statement on the envelopes saying the signature on said envelope has been verified by local election officials.

The state Secretary of State’s office said the practice in question is a “simple administrative procedure” and that the suit is an “abuse of our judicial system and a waste of all our time.”

“This lawsuit could have been an email,” said spokesperson Angela Benander. “This is not about the law, our processes, or election administration. It’s about getting a headline that causes voters to doubt the integrity of our election processes.”

Michigan Republican Party Chairman Pete Hoekstra claimed in a statement that the Secretary of State was “interfering in Michigan’s elections, disregarding the very laws she’s supposed to enforce.”

Absentee ballots and digital voter IDs in North Carolina

On Tuesday, the RNC and North Carolina state Republican party filed a lawsuit against the State Board of Elections questioning the integrity of absentee ballot policy. The suit argues that board revisions to absentee ballot law conflicted with state statute requiring ballots to be sealed for it to count.

RNC Chairman Michael Whatley said in a statement that the board’s decision was “inconsistent with state law and diminishes protections for absentee ballots.”

“We have filed suit to uphold election integrity and ballot safeguards,” Whatley said.

In a separate lawsuit filed Thursday against the board, the RNC and state Republican party argued a state court should block a University of North Carolina-Chapel Hill policy which allows students and employees to use digital IDs for in-person voting.

In August, the state election board voted 3-2 to approve the use of UNC-issued digital IDs for voting, but Republicans say the IDs do not comply with state voter ID law.

“When the NCSBE majority wrongly approved use of this so-called Digital ID, we said we would not stand for it,” said state party Chairman Jason Simmons in a statement. “This lawsuit will ensure that Voter ID laws are faithfully followed in North Carolina elections.”

This is the RNC’s fourth lawsuit against the election board.

Voter rolls in Nevada

Meanwhile, in Nevada, the RNC and Nevada GOP sued the Secretary of State Francisco Aguilar, arguing that his office is allowing non-citizens to register to vote despite state officials maintaining there are protections in place that prevent that from happening.

“Only United States citizens are eligible to vote in Nevada’s elections. There are already numerous safeguards in place to prevent noncitizens, or anyone ineligible to vote, from casting a ballot,” a statement from the Nevada Secretary of State’s Office said. “Any claims of a widespread problem are false and only create distrust in our elections.”

Republicans, however, claim there is evidence of “thousands” of non-citizens on voter rolls who could cast their vote in November and influence election outcomes.

“Allowing non-citizens to vote suppresses legal voters, undermines the democratic system, and violates the law,” Whatley said.

The suit also targets Nevada Democrats, who Republicans argue are supporting the alleged practice.

The suit claims that the election body does not check DMV records or federal databases, arguing Nevada lacks basic citizenship verification procedures in its voter roll processes.
Tags Jocelyn Benson Joe Biden Michael Whatley