So gonna tackle a subject here that in the past has gotten some interesting responses. Freewill. Does it really exist? Ages ago when I was in college one of my favorite subjects was psychology. I forget which psych class it was but I decided to do a research paper on Freewill. By the time I was done my world view was drastically changed. When I turned in my paper to the professor I stayed behind to speak with her. I looked at her as both stated and asked, "Freewill is an illusion..?"
She looked at me with a Cheshire cat grin and just nodded slowly. So what say you? Do we have freewill or do we not?
3
Enjoy being online again!
Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.Create your free account
7 comments
Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.I watched some philosophy debates-alot of evidence
is pushing in the NO direction . From the idea of who
and where you are born to what will be asked of you and
when. I tend to agree with the premise that freewill is curtailed or near non-existent. We as a culture like to
tout it, but the more immediate constraints (location;age
;background;genes;ECT.) restrict individual objectives.
Good post!
BBJong
Level 7
Nov 2, 2019
0
Never heard anyone give a convincing argument that there is no free will at all, just that it is severely restricted...which it is. But if there is no free will at all, then no one chooses to believe in free will or not to believe in free will, because their own belief one way or the other is determined and beyond their control. So there is no point arguing about it in that case because we are all just acting out deterministic scripts of the universe.
Heraclitus
Level 8
Oct 27, 2019
1
I see the level of choice connected to how it is veiwed
socially and culturally.In context we must remain
realistic for choice to be a factor.
Look at it this way. All your choices are based on your DNA and life experiences. In any given situation where you have multiple possible choices there really is only one choixe you can make. Every time you are placed in that same situation with the same choice and knowing the same information you will always make the same choice. The only way you could make a different choice is if you are given additional information.
@Norman347
Exactly, but we are constantly given additional information. Being alive means you are constantly taking in new information. If you are not constantly taking in new information, you are dead.
Yes, we have free will.. Why does this question cause so much debate?
Cutiebeauty
Level 9
Oct 27, 2019
0
Price it. How do you figure we have free will and not the illusion of it?
@Norman347 an illusion of free will.. I guess you can say everything is an illusion... But that doesn't make sense to me..
I think causes have natural responses and we get patterns from that. But it seems to me we can step in at any given time and reject the intuitive reaction. Perhaps the argument against that is that even the rejection is the result of a cause we can't see because we don't see the big picture.
brentan
Level 8
Oct 27, 2019
1
I think those who said this illusion (more correctly it is an incomplete thaught )they may be informed that it create a motive force to go ahead. Our task is to choose whether it can be followed to get an output or to reject it if there is no output possibility within a time frsme.
allmighty
Level 6
Oct 27, 2019
1
Action and reaction in physics would suggest not. But then the quantum world is strong with items appearing and disappearing for no reason.
I am sure we can forget brain functionality, whichever way we go!
Geoffrey51
Level 8
Oct 27, 2019
1
There is order and cause and effect at the quantum level as well. We just don't understand it yet.
@Norman347 Then probably no free will that we would understand.
No the quantum is also driven by cause and effect. It just appears weird because we don't understand the causes yet. Just like how nothing in the universe is random. We use the term when we don't understand the cause and effect going on. It just appears random to us because we lack the required information to see the causality.
Recent Visitors 17
Redmon17
NC, USA
Heraclitus
NC, USA
Cutiebeauty
West Bubble Fuck,
Geoffrey51
Australia
Norman347
AZ, USA
Photos 191 More
Posted by johnnyrobishWell, somebody had to do it!
Posted by WalterGreensTo every one out there!
Posted by LenHazell53Well would you look at that, and who posted it
Posted by Mike-IMAOpinions base on facts and evidence can change the world.
Posted by ChrisAineWhere is everybody? Don't tell me y'all caught up with Xmas festivities. Anyway Merry Christmas free thinkers. May you get a kiss under the mistletoe..😊
Posted by ScribblerWhy is everyone leaving?
Posted by AryabratIsn't this the most logical and simplistic way to dismiss a fictitious superpower/hero? Or is there anymore way?
Posted by AvaBunWhat are your thoughts?
Posted by terenaskawsHow passionate are you in creating?
Posted by SpinlieselToday, in 1872, the last Indian war east of the Mississippi ended with the capture of Black Hawk.
Posted by SlarsAnother throw back from my orange years.. mad to think they essentially just paid us to play with big toys all day fun job...
Posted by AnabuceriasPhoto is worth 1000 words.
Posted by bobwjrThat's this group
Posted by TourirstMIA: Missing in Administration. I have posted this, twice and of course, it slides under the radar, understandably as Admin has left the building for good?
Posted by LorajayThis is a wonderful way to live as long as you take care of the necessities of providing for food and shelter first.
Posted by phxbillceeCongratulations, @Marionville on reaching Level 10!!!