Agnostic.com

8 2

I have recently read the 2014 book “Reality is not What it Seems”, by Carlo Rovelli, an acclaimed theoretical physicist. The book is about the current status of quantum gravity research, also called loop quantum gravity, and it is written for us laypeople. The implications of quantum gravity are mind boggling. While I don’t fully understand the book, I got enough to be thoroughly dazzled. Rovelli gives the reader an extensive history of physics, going back to the Ancient Greek philosophers.

Quantum gravity theory tells us, in brief, that space is not the smooth, continuous expanse that we usually think of. Space is a network whose nodes represent grains or quanta of space. Space is a field. Space is not infinite, nor is it infinitely divisible. There is no place for infinity in quantum gravity theory.

Matter does not consist of particles moving in space. Quantum mechanics has already done away with the particle as a thing concept—there are only quantum fields. The world is a sequence of discrete events. A particle is a temporary event, an interaction of fields, or lines within a field.

Reality does not consist of matter moving in space and time. Reality is made out of fields—covariant quantum fields which are primary. Everything that we think of as existing: matter, light, energy, space and time—all are manifestations of covariant quantum fields. According to Rovelli what we perceive as reality is a crude and symbolic version of the quantum gravity field. In this higher reality there is no such thing as time, just relationships.

The ideas are hard to fathom, but this subject whets my already almost religious worship of nature with all its awe-filling mystery. I highly recommend the book. Do not be deterred by my wide-eyed spiritual orientation—Rovelli is safely in the atheist camp. 🙂

WilliamFleming 8 July 1
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

8 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

I am fascinated by this notion: The thought creates the word. The word creates the reality.

1

Thank you for this good book recommendation!

2

Consensus reality is what we all live by.

3

Sounds Good.
Also, my lack of belief does not mean I discount believers of their ideas out of hand.
Newton was a believer and had some good ideas
So did Ghandi
We might disagree on belief in God, but if I judge the world based on that SINGLE issue, I have made myself into a Bigot looking down on others with whom I disagree on a single point.

Thanks no.
But the Book sounds interesting.

2

Is there any experiment that can provide evidence whether Signor Rovelli's ideas are correct or not?

Ideas without empirical evidence are eternally half-baked science. It was Arthur Eddington who make Albert Einstein famous.

Chapter nine is entitled “Empirical Confirmations”. There’s this: “...The theory is in its infancy. It’s theoretical apparatus is gaining solidarity, and the fundamental ideas are being clarified; the clues are good, and concrete—confirmed predictions are still missing. The theory has not yet taken its exams.” Various evidence is presented.

3

The review wasn't "starry eyed". Thanks, I'll look for it.

3

Since we don't operate in that higher field, it's not really relevant to our everyday life is it?

Not really relevant for survival. Animals know nothing of quantum gravity, and most of them do well.

The ideas are fascinating to curious folks, and some day they may be of practical use.

2

It sounds really good. I'm going to look for it.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:120488
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.