Agnostic.com

8 0

Do you think of Jewishness as a race, a religion, or both?

[google.com]

Hermit 7 July 20
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

8 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

Probably note appropriate for anyone who is not Jewish to comment

1

Actually, Jewish is not a race technically. There is no race specific gene in the human genome. Because humans have become so ubiquitous across the Esrth, evety groups of DNA have ultimately been shared with all other group' DNA.. Therefore it is quite accurate to say there is no such thing as "race" in humans.

Races do occur in the animal kingdom. But it usually takes populations becoming isolated for thousands of years before they can be considered a distinct race. Their Gene Pool must have changed enough from the original population such that it is uniquely and distinctly diiferent.

What makes groups of people do different. One is Natural Selection. Groups living closer to the equator produce more melatonin than those closer to the poles. Therefore, if you clive closer to the equator, you are naturally going to select a mate that has more melatonin (darker in skin color) because that person is more evolutionarily fit for that geographic location. This is known as sexual selection.

Jewishness is a culture and a religion. Many Jewish people look alike because they originally lived in the same geographic area; the Middle East. Because of the amount of sunlight they adapted slightly darker skin (what is often referred to as olive skin tone). Because of the bonding formed by the culture and the religion, Jews looked for similar minded mates. And since slightly darker skin was indicative of better evolutionary fitness, they naturally chose a particular physical type. Because of this selection process they cemented certain physical characteristics into their Gene pool.

This is true of any similar looking groups of people eg. Scandinavians for instance. Not all cultures and religions are as cohesive and therefore reflect greater ranges of characteristics.

t1nick Level 8 July 20, 2018
0

Primarily, heredity.. Though the palistinians, and others in the region, are also genetically Semites.

Then there are keepers of the faith: the zionists: one of the most racist groups of people on the planet.

JacarC Level 8 July 20, 2018
0

Both. Some Jews see it more as an ethnicity, some more as a religion, many as both. And as others have pointed out ... my thoroughly Gentile self could decide this very night to convert to Judaism, despite no past racial or religious affiliation, so in that sense for some people it's purely a religion. Come to think of it, my wife knows a gentile convert to a fundamentalist / separatist Jewish sect who has identified as a religious Jew since right after they were in high school together.

0

Well I thought it meant you were a descendant of the tribe of Judah so I would consider a race with very specific religious traditions.

2

Ask Jewish people what they think.

Judaism is not a race. People can convert to or leave the Jewish faith. That is not true of a race.

I was raised in a Jewish home. I’ve always thought of it as a religion/culture. I’ve never felt like I was a part of a Jewish race.

1

It’s tradition and culture, right?

According to that judge in Louisiana, it’s a race.

2

"Judaism can be thought of as being simultaneously a religion, a nationality and a culture.

"Throughout the middle ages and into the 20th century, most of the European world agreed that Jews constituted a distinct nation. This concept of nation does not require that a nation have either a territory nor a government, but rather, it identifies, as a nation any distinct group of people with a common language and culture. Only in the 19th century did it become common to assume that each nation should have its own distinct government; this is the political philosophy of nationalism. In fact, Jews had a remarkable degree of self-government until the 19th century. So long as Jews lived in their ghettos, they were allowed to collect their own taxes, run their own courts, and otherwise behave as citizens of a landless and distinctly second-class Jewish nation.

"Of course, Judaism is a religion, and it is this religion that forms the central element of the Jewish culture that binds Jews together as a nation. It is the religion that defines foods as being kosher and non-kosher, and this underlies Jewish cuisine. It is the religion that sets the calendar of Jewish feast and fast days, and it is the religion that has preserved the Hebrew language.

"Is Judaism an ethnicity? In short, not any more. Although Judaism arose out of a single ethnicity in the Middle East, there have always been conversions into and out of the religion. Thus, there are those who may have been ethnically part of the original group who are no longer part of Judaism, and those of other ethnic groups who have converted into Judaism.

"If you are referring to a nation in the sense of race, Judaism is not a nation. People are free to convert into Judaism; once converted, they are considered the same as if they were born Jewish. This is not true for a race."

[jewishvirtuallibrary.org]

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:135719
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.