Agnostic.com

2 0

"In Homer, magic has been abolished. It is practically nonexistent in the Iliad and the Odyssey. The enormous spiritual advance this shows—and intellectual, no less—is hard for us to realize. Before Greece all religion was magical. Magic was of supreme importance. It was mankind’s sole defense against fearful powers leagued against mankind. Myriads of malignant spirits were bent on bringing every kind of evil to it. They were omnipresent. A Chaldean inscription runs:
.
They lie in wait. They twine around the rafters. They take their way from house to house and the door cannot stop them. They separate the bride from the embraces of the bridegroom; they snatch the child from between his father’s knees.
.
Life was possible only because, fearful as they were, they could be appeased or weakened by magical means. These were often terrible as well as senseless. The human mind played no part at all in the whole business. It was enslaved by terror. A magical universe was so terrifying because it was so irrational, and therefore completely incalculable. There was no dependable relation anywhere between cause and effect. It will readily be seen what it did to the human intellect to live in such an atmosphere, and what it did to the human character, too. Fear is of all the emotions the most brutalizing.
In this terror-haunted world a strange thing came to pass. In one little country the terror was banished. For untold ages it had dominated mankind and stunted its growth. The Greeks dismissed it. They changed a world that was full of fear into a world full of beauty. We have not the least idea when or how this extraordinary change came about. We know only that in Homer men are free and fearless. There are no fearful powers to be propitiated in fearful ways. Very humanlike gods inhabit a very delightful heaven. Strange and terrifying unrealities—shapes made up of bird and beast and human joined together by artists who thought only the unhuman could be divine—have no place in Greece. The universe has become rational. An early Greek philosopher wrote: “All things were in confusion until Mind came and set them in order.” That mind was Greek, and the first exponent of it we know about was Homer. In the Iliad and the Odyssey mankind has been delivered from the terror of the unhuman supreme over the human.
"
.
The Greek Way Edith Hamilton

THHA 7 Mar 21
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

2 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

I enjoyed this post.

I found Julian Jaynes observations of the Illiad vs Homer intriguing in "The Origins of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind" intriguing.

The theory being the differences from the former to the latter have to do with the increases in fiber connectivity in the corpus collosum fascilitated this change in cognition.

Given we all know the difference bit width in computer connectivity makes to performance and capacity, I think Jayne's thesis merits consideration.

-Joe

1

Read your long exchange with Gwendolyn2 below. (Long hard read.) But absolutes do not exist or matter either way, there is, it is true, little superstition in Homer, but the ancient Greeks certainly had some, even Plato wrote about the oracle. What really matters about that culture, is that on a few occasions, a few people like Aristotle living on Lesbos, went down to the sea shore and though it worthwhile, to try cataloging the many glittering sea creatures he found. Sowing as he did so, the seed of an idea that the natural world could be something worthy of study, in a purely natural way; and was not just the inexplicable gift of equally inexplicable supernatural beings. Like you I too think that there is both high romance and great reality in that, and would love if it were possible to go back and walk down to that beach one golden morning , just to see the wonder of reason being born as a new route to truth.

You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:315405
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.