Agnostic.com

5 4

Bain Dramage.

"A study published in the journal Neuropsychologia has shown that religious fundamentalism is, in part, the result of a functional impairment in a brain region known as the prefrontal cortex."

[salon.com]

TrailRider 7 Apr 18
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

5 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

Association is not cause.

Asserting that people with whom you don't agree are brain-damaged is pretty much ceding the debate with bad-faith arguments.

All the study really said is that people with a certain kind of cognitive impairment were more likely to be fundamentalists. I would suspect they would also be more likely to be politically conservative. So??

One must always remember that statistics don't have a mechanism for determining causality, only association. In statistics, it is VERY easy to get causality exactly backwards. For all we know, fundamentalism causes cognitive impairment (not the same as physical brain damage) rather than the inverse. But more likely, both certain brain injuries and being steeped in certain thought patterns, cause similar impairments with similar features.

This study and the articles about it are more heat than light; they produce nice click-bait. But don't take their explanatory power that seriously.

In fairness to the author of this piece, buried near the end, beyond the attention span of many eager readers, is the admission that poor functioning of the prefrontal cortex only accounts for about 20% of the factors influencing fundamentalism, and so there are many other influences (or at least associations) to tease out. They didn't lead with that because it makes the premise of the article far less provocative, stand-out and interesting.

0

I’d be wary about using Salon as a “reputable” news source.

Especially a Salon article republished from Raw Story.

On the other hand they are describing a serious scientific analysis which should stand or fall on its own merits. That study is available to be read directly:

[ncbi.nlm.nih.gov]

0

Thank you for sharing this!

1

That's interesting. Near the end of my marriage, I became extreme in my religious beliefs. I personally believe that was a reaction to the ongoing abuse I was experiencing.

On the upside, it worked to finally help me see that those beliefs were not valid. A couple years after the divorce, as I began to heal, I realized that none of the things I had believed would happen due to my "obedience to God" were happening. If anything, the reverse was happening. So I was able to let those things go completely.

Sounds like you went through some serious trauma. That does make sense.

1

I don't believe that for a moment.

What don't you believe and why? Thank you.

@Heathenman I don't believe "that religious fundamentalism is, in part, the result of a functional impairment in a brain region known as the prefrontal cortex."

I believe the impulse to worship and the brain apparatus to rationalise it are a tribute to the imaginative powers of the brain and suggest an ability rather than a malfunction.

@brentan I agree with that. Thank you for your response and time.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:333107
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.