Agnostic.com

3 2

If someone murders another as a crime of passion do we consider that the person had a criminal mindset or that they have committed a criminal act?

Geoffrey51 8 May 6
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

3 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

The answer to both questions is yes. They knew what they were doing was criminal and they did it anyway, but because of passion they supposedly had an excuse. That's why manslaughter is punished less severely than first or second-degree murder.

lerlo Level 8 May 7, 2019
1

I think a person who commits a "crime of passion" is more likely to commit another "crime of passion". So, I dotn' see how a "crime of passion" shoudl be differentiated all that much from other murders.

Have you ever been married? Or been seriously involved with a male for a long period of time? If you caught your partner or that boy friend in bed with your best friend what would your reaction be? What if you had children? If you walked into your next door neighbor's house and found him raping your six-year-old daughter what would you do? They call them crimes of passion because many people are prone to violence in such situations. Perhaps I didn't mention a situation that would evoke your passion and maybe there's nothing in the world that would cause you to act out. But for many people, when the most important person in their life is harmed or breaks their trust, society tends to give them a lesser punishment when they might not be able to control their actions. I disagree with you that serial killers who go around killing people for kicks are the same as people who need someone they care about deeply to be harmed before they react. There is a major difference between premeditated murder, reckless indifference to murder and a passionate occurrence.

@lerlo I have had somr relationship where I was hurt a great deal. I move on with my life. I dont' let those who betray me remain in my life. I feel no need to be violent about it.

@snytiger6 you didn't address my scenarios which go way beyond a great deal of hurt. I wasn't suggesting that you could kill somebody, just trying to make you understand why some people do.

2

I think you just have to say they’ve committed a criminal act and must pay the penalty for that act. If they have a history of such acts they might be punished more severely.

I don’t know if “criminal mindset” is a valid idea. “Criminal” is whatever legislators say is criminal.

Laws, especially the so called crimes of passions, vary from state to state and country to country. There are still places in the States where (usually the man) can kill their partner and their partner's lover if caught in the act.

@Beowulfsfriend I see. I was thinking in more general terms.

I’m going to have to be more careful from here out with my liaisons

You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:342713
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.