Agnostic.com

5 2

Is populism democracy in action? If so, does it provide a satisfactory political result? My jury is out on this one.

Geoffrey51 8 May 24
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

5 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

Populism can be part of any ideology be it Trump's political base who hate intellectual ideas and call them elitist, or the Occupy movement who were the 99% against the economic inequality perpetrated by the elite, or a popular social-democracy movement which is against the elitism of state facism.

2

Marx thought that man's alienation was due to the separation of man from what he makes, from the products of his labor. State ideologies attempt to give reason for the labor, to force interpretation under the existing ideological frameworks, whether it's republican, democratic, socialistic, right winged or left winged, communist. However, the French Yellow Vests protests are headless, they do not have an agenda (Macron crumbled on his fuel tax) or leaders at this point...6 months of protests and counting. They appear to be the protesting of the plight of the working poor against the tax avoiding rich.

As a wall in Paris states:

"a bas le caviar vive le kebab"
"Down with caviar, long live kebab"

cava Level 7 May 24, 2019
0

Population, does not bring desirable results. It is more of a Band Wagon Phenomena. Problem is sometimes the band wagon heads otu to a desolate desert, or over a cliff.

Trump is an example of populism.

0

Depends on what you mean by populism. If you mean politicians taking cognisance of what the majority of the population want, then that would seem to be real democracy. But if you mean the manipulation of ignorant people by billionaire-controlled media and self-serving demagogues, democracy hardly comes into it.

I was referring to the latter in the context of the electorate voting for charisma instead of policy.

@Geoffrey51 That is a problem we have in the UK. People have got used to the idea that people you listen to have to be glamorous TV types and they complain that Jeremy Corbyn is boring and uncharismatic while entirely agreeing with his policies. At the same time they believe every lying word that 'personalities'tell them. Sometimes I despair - most of the time in fact.

@CeliaVL Scary isn’t it. We are lucky in Australia. No charisma culture in politics at the moment. The populist just have ideas for a minority section of voters. One spent $60m of his own money on the campaign and came out with nothing. In fact his popularity dropped by half by the last week of the campaign. That’s what I love about Australians. They generally love a laugh and josh around but if you take yourself too seriously it’s all over,

0

I’m thinking about that.

Double points. 🙂

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:351475
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.