Agnostic.com

4 2

Is racism a fact or an opinion?

Stemming from an argument with a Facebook friend who's a Trump supporter and claims the wall isn't racist. Told me to provide proof it was racist. So, of course, I went to Google since I'm nowhere near omniscient.

Provided her with a couple of articles and a couple of infographics. She disputed the articles as not being fact because they were both from opinion pages.

My response was, well, racism has the suffix -ism which makes it inherently an opinion anyway.

One of the results in my Google search stated this and expanded on it by saying racism can be a truth but not a fact.

The argument never went anywhere because she couldn't provide proof the wall isn't racist and wouldn't accept my proof it was. Ended up devolving into personal attacks which I let slide because I knew I was getting under her skin and her tiny brain just couldn't handle that Trump is racist.

So, anyway, back to the core question- is racism an opinion or a fact?

Addendum- I'm on shift in an hour until 7 am tomorrow morning. So, my apologies when I disappear.

Melbates 7 Mar 20
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

4 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

I live on the edge of Albuquerque and you really don't want to go to the South Valley part of town where the traffic from the border first hits ABQ because it is dangerous there. The addicts from there come up to the Westside and steal money from houses there, sometimes they get shot, sometimes they kill those at home, lots of times there's no one in.

If you are a wealthy liberal in a gated community in California you can say no one needs guns and we don't need a wall, after all the ground keeper is from Mexico, but if you live here you can't say either of those things even though the newspaper keeps saying them.

Where did the wealthy liberal in a gated community in California come from? Please clarify your comment. It's obvious you were responding emotionally, not rationally because your comment doesn't make sense.

No, it's anecdotal, I've heard a comment from someone in a gated community protected by armed guards that we don't need guns, by someone in England that we don't need a wall, England being protected by a 20 mile wide and carefully monitored English Channel and that we don't need a wall/fence by someone just 20 miles from where the drug related killings are going on.

Lots of hypocrisy, we don't need to solve it as long as it is someone else's problem.

Politics is full of it. We don't care if car factories move out of the country because we aren't car workers, etc.

1

Racism is a fact. It is firmly interwoven into the life experiences of P.O.C and I think a majority (population) member denying its existence or trying to deflect is in itself, indicative of privilege.

@bibliophile_xo As stated, racism can be a truth but not a fact. My friend Mordant gives the definition of racism in his comment below. The key word in the definition is the word "belief" i.e. an opinion. The definition of the word "fact" is a thing that is indisputably the case. Example: my cat's hair is gray.

I understand how racism can be interwoven into POC's lives. I know there are situations that POC's experience which a white chick like me could never fathom and I am deeply sorry for this having such an effect on your life. Racism is a truth. Racism is everywhere. I'd never been witness to racist situations until I grew up. When I was in school, skin color didn't matter. You were teased for wearing glasses or having jacked teeth but not your skin color. It was not something I witnessed growing up.

Again, I'm sorry that lovely people such as yourself have experienced racism but don't see how it's a fact. 😟 I would love for you to change my mind, though.

1

Well here's the definition of "racist": prejudice, discrimination, or antagonism directed against someone of a different race based on the belief that one's own race is superior.

The problem is that prejudice, discrimation and antagnoism is all in the eye of the beholder, and people often hold more subtle, structural racist views and attitutes and protect their self-image as good, non-hateful people with that plausible deniability. This is the source of many sterotypes and tropes of clueless people who think they're enlightened, such as someone saying "but some of my best friends are wetbacks".

By itself a wall is just a wall and you can couch the need for it in terms of "border security", so I don't know that it's a very effective to argue that it's inherently racist. That's a non-falsifiable assumption unless you can successfully argue that anything that has limiting consequences on a particular race, intended or not, is effectively "racist" by complicity. And then you're just going to get accused of being ridiculously politically correct.

It's a real problem because most people who are not inclusive and accepting of diversity aren't actively out lynching people or something and if you point out how non-diverse their community is, to them it just sort of happened by itself, no one MADE it happen. It's kind of like someone who can't smell their own B.O. I don't pretend to know how to overcome that but it's probably not in discussions like the one you're describing.

I saw a startling example of the compartmentalization and disconnect I'm talking about here. An interviewer was talking to a Trump supporter and border wall advocate who was adamant that we needed to keep these undesirable elements out. Later on he takes the interviewer to see his pride and joy, a school for disadvantaged youth (this was in Houston I believe), mostly latino, and described with tears in his eyes, how anyone could attend by simply paying what they can afford. One woman had no money but agreed to provide tacos for the school lunches.

So here was a guy on the one hand showing love and acceptance and personal sacrifice on behalf of immigrants and the disadvantaged with none of the standard-issue cruel insiutations that they're lazy or it's all their fault somehow, and on the other hand, wanting to build a wall to keep them out. Go figure. I assume that meeting people in his neighborhood and actually knowing them humanizes them; but the ones "over there" in Mexico are faceless threats.

This is why bringing people together to meet face-to-face is SO crucial to getting anywhere with this kind of thing.

@mordant When I think of Trump's wall as inherently racist, I first think of the wall in Palestine and then think of Trump's reasoning for his wall. To me, that's why it's inherently racist.

If Trump really cares about securing the borders, why is his wall only intended for our southern border? We have a border with Canada as well. Trumps whole platform is by definition racists. The justification for the wall he used during the campaign was directed at Mexicans and even his suggestion that Mexico will pay for the wall, was racists. It’s not difficult to argue that the wall is racists.

I have a real problem in all honesty with Trump and everything he stands for and does. If it ain’t white male, it is inherently inferior to him. More specifically if it ain’t Donald Trump it’s inferior. That is clear with every word, and every action.

Apologies if I come off sounding like I’m angry in any way. Not my intent. I’m only making a point about his character.

@ChrisJones I attempted to make that point to the "friends" on my Facebook post. I also attempted to point out they can still enter via the gulf coast or west coast. I do not want to turn into Palestine with a 70 foot cement wall surrounding every inch of our land.

@Melbates I don't really disagree with you. I was talking about relatively sane people's mental landscape; once we start discussing Trump or some of the extremists in his orbit, their true colors become clearer, less veiled and deniable. But I think most people are just not self-aware enough to see their own privilege / inconsistency / whatever.

@ChrisJones Yes I agree. I think it's repugnant and while I'm sure proponents would say (without evidence) that all the drugs and illegals are coming in across the southern border, not the northern, that's not their real concern. Illegal immigrants are flying in and staying way more than coming across the actual border, and there are plenty of drugs moving across the Canadian border too. It's only our affinity with the predominantly white European makeup of Canada that makes it seem less of a threat; there's not anything substantively real either about the southern threat or the northern harmlessness.

What I was really going for was a bit of empathy for Joe Average Conservative; I'm still somehow willing to see them as misguided and manipulated / conned more than malignant so long as they're not alt-right types. The latter, and Trump, and large parts of fundamentalist Christianity and post-Tea-Party Republican muck-a-mucks, are beyond redemption in my view, but I'm not quite ready to write off nearly half of my fellow Americans as such. Yet. Dog knows, I'm getting there, though.

Oh ... and no offense taken. 🙂

@mordant I agree. Not ready to write off all my fellow Americans who voted for Trump. There’s an old saying that comes to mind. ‘There’s a sucker born every minute.’ A good conman or conwoman as the case may be can always find a way to exploit the suckers. That’s what I believe Trump has done. Some of those who voted for Trump are racists. But I think there are more who just weren’t aware or just couldn’t see past the lies. At least that’s what I want to believe. The alternative is not the America I grew up in, nor is it the America I believe we should be.

@Melbates no arguments there. We should be building bridges. Not walls. The moment we decide to put up walls, is the moment we lose America as we know it. We may already be there. But I’m hoping that cooler and calmer heads will prevail and stand up for what is right.

0

I'm not sure how to answer this. I agree with your arguments though.

Racism exists and there are plenty of racists out there, including Trump. The idea that makes a person a racists is based on an opinion. An opinion that is by definition not a common opinion and is therefore not a fact. So a person who is racist or sexist or other ist, is using a personal opinion about the color of someones skin or the gender of someone as a reason to hate them or label them in some way as inferior. The reality is that it's not legitimate. I've never understood the arguments of racists. Growing up I made friends easily with anyone. It was not until I got into middle school that I even had an idea that racism was a thing. We don't see difference until someone teaches us that a difference means something to some people. It's what we choose to believe that makes it a problem.

@chrisjones I agree with you that I didn't know of racism until I was much older. My generation didn't experience the same situations as the generations that experienced the first black children in school and the like. My friend Mordant commented above and gave the definition of the word racism. The key word in the definition is the word "belief" i.e. an opinion.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:40563
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.