Agnostic.com

5 3

Rush wants to show how smart he is!

"Could you be somewhere and witness this Big Bang instead of being a part of it? If so, where were you? Well, since nobody could see it, how the hell do they know it really happened? But I’m not supposed to ask that."

[patheos.com]

Angelface 7 Mar 24
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

5 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

Damn he's stupid!

0

JUst look at the size if it were a little bang we might see the end.

1

I classify Rush as a cynical manipulator of / panderer to the hyperconservative / fundamentalist base. He is simply pushing buttons. I doubt he even half believes most of his own bullshit; it's quite possible he doesn't believe it at all.

His audience favors arguments from incredulity like this. The BB is inferred based on math and indirect observation. If you're scientifically incurious or illiterate then it is easy for it to not feel "truthy". It doesn't help that the BB was discovered and explained by eggheads, who such people feel insecure around at best, and are disdainful of at worst. It doesn't help that it's a product of science, which fundamentalism actively portrays as unreliable and capriciously "changing its mind" all the time, often using laughably specious arguments to back up this charge, such as that science used to say that the earth is flat, now it says it's spherical (flat earth was in fact a prescientific argument and even at that not as universally accepted as most people think).

Basically, anything to undermine confidence in the scientific method, which has the best possible track record of reliability and improving the human condition of anything we know [sigh].

1

That is funny. I have been having conversations lately that tend to center at some point on the big bang. While it is true we were not there to see it does not mean we can not ascertain that sequence of events. If you find a window broken and a baseball on the floor in the glass you "know" with out having seen that the ball broke the glass. For the big bang we look at the radio wave signature that we have found and the paterns and movments of the materials in space and we get a very good idea of what happened.

Ldox Level 4 Mar 24, 2018
1

A Physics theory states that it takes an observer to collapse the wave function to determine reality.
He probably read that in a Physics book and put his own spin on it. I don't believe he is intelligent enough to understand Physics.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:42700
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.