Agnostic.com

5 3

We easily see the role of religion in trying to alter human behavior, so that it is tempting to see all aspects as something imposed to control our basic nature, and thus something to be rejected. Religion also reflects real aspects of human nature, and I think it is useful to examine these and often to reclaim them as our own instead of a blanket rejection as being part of theism. One of these that interests me is monasticism. It comes up in remarkably similar forms in pretty much every major religion. People live outside of society for the most part, simply, but within a world of art and knowledge. In western civilization, monasteries were the time capsules that carried much that would otherwise have been lost in the Dark Ages. I think that just as some are born gay, some are born monastic, and perhaps we have evolved this way because there is a strong evolutionary argument for such time capsule groups serving humanity over much of our existence on earth. Anyone feel that they were born with monastic traits?

DavidDuhon 7 Nov 19
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

5 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

Nope. I really, really like women, and I can get really, really tired of my own thoughts.

1

Great post! Yes, I'm a natural born hermit.

skado Level 9 Nov 20, 2019

@Allamanda
For me it's not about any kind of absolutism or extremism. I have friends, enjoy being with people, go into town often, etc. and have lived in town for periods, but I have never married, and have always needed lots of time to recover after social engagement. I can't say I totally love being alone every minute of my life, but I'd be able to deal with that a lot easier than finding myself in a contentious partnership.

3

Monasticism does have a secular tradition, besides a religious one. Besides the many modern communities, the Epicurians in classical times established a whole range of communities, across the Roman Empire, which probably provided the inspiration for the Christian monastic tradition.

1

I think that I lean toward monasticism in some ways. I like country life, but you can also live in a city and have monastic traits.

I would not want to be a total hermit however.

2

Definitely. My idea of heaven, to use a term, was living alone with my Springer Spaniel, tramping over the cliffs by the sea in the south of England!

I’m okay with people but prefer solitude. I’ve lived in cities and rural areas. The cities are no good for me. That’s London, Melbourne and Boston all the same, but different with an underlying sense of urgency.

Give me a dog and a place in the country. Nothing else needed.😊

@DavidDuhon Definelty hermit. Can’t be doing with any of that community intrusion!

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:428523
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.