Agnostic.com

6 5

So, should we be isolating, or protesting? [theguardian.com]

Allamanda 8 June 9
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

6 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

Sure move freely as though there is not a pandemic currently going on if you don't give a damn about public health, which quite a huge number of Americans do not. The lives, including black lives, lost to covid will far outweigh lives lost in police interactions by hundredfold and much, much more.

Additionally how is the racism explanation still being being used as primary explanation for Floyd's murder when Floyd's own brother states the two men knew each other and Chauvin had a personal dislike for Floyd. This seemed obvious from the start. Floyd wasn't just an unknown black man to Chauvin, but someone who WAS known. Floyd is described as personable, what would constitute disliking if it was not racism? It opens up larger questions about the Minneapolis Police Department, or parts of it. Why is noone asking the attached questions related to this case?

@Allamanda "disbanding the entire force there." Why is this call being made NOW when transparency in department is MOST needed? Hmmm. Why? I will reask the question, where is the information that states majority of constituents support this idea? Government is supposed to be "we the people", where are the "people" in this discussion and decision making process? Or are we supposed to believe the narrative that one protest in which Mayor of Minneapolis is booed for not supporting disbanding is representative of the People's voice?

Please support this statement with facts "polices' impunity in targeting and killing black people." And if you can prove this statement to be true , calls to disband the police make me believe the true intentions of those calling for it at this point in time are advocating for obfuscation of the true extent of the problem and true nature of what has occurred. If it is racism LET IT BE KNOWN. If it is something else, LET IT BE KNOWN.

Additionally I treated protestors unfairly in my opening sentence. There were MANY protesting with masks.

@Allamanda Here is our modern day plutocratic control shining clearly for the world to see "The council members who took part in the announcement included Cam Gordon, Steve Fletcher, Phillipe Cunningham, Jeremiah Ellison, Andrea Jenkins, Alondra Cano, Lisa Bender and Jeremy Schroeder. The announcement comes after various entities such as the University of Minnesota, Minneapolis Public Schools, First Avenue, and others decided to end or limit their relationship with the police department." (Said of "A veto-proof majority of Minneapolis City Council members announced Sunday during a rally at Powderhorn Park that they are planning to disband the police department." ) Unless you can show me where the majority of constituents support this idea in scientifically collected data, I will not believe the actions of the few to be an honest representation of the People's will.

@Allamanda "no doubt you have six more tangents in store." Probably MORE. Don't underestimate.

I didn't know you were supportive of plutocratic aims. Thanks for clearing that up.

You said "again" please refer me to the first time you cited dismantling of police as being the will of the people.

@Allamanda Go for it! I will continue to question whether it's the will of the people irregardless. Hopefully more people will too.

@Allamanda "In the ongoing debate over policing in Minneapolis, it’s been difficult to get a pulse on public sentiment. Thanks to a new citywide survey, that’s no longer the case....Among respondents of color, 65% supported adding 250 officers." [m.startribune.com]

@Allamanda And an additional tangent. "Dr. Deborah Birx, President Trump’s coronavirus response coordinator, warned the nation’s governors on a conference call that 70 coronavirus testing sites had been destroyed amid widespread protests in the wake of the death of George Floyd." [yahoo.com] This article hasn't even mentioned the destruction of pharmacies or other health facilities.

1

Old and high risk isolate

bobwjr Level 10 June 9, 2020
1

I'm six months pregnant.. Isolation for me.. Otherwise...protest!

@Allamanda you know it! 😊

0

Protesting with social distancing. I know that can be difficult, but it can be done. I remember seeing White men with guns in the state capital buildings in Michigan. Trump supporters out protesting. I have seen Black lives matter protesters behaving more responsibly than the Trump supporters. Peaceful protesters being charged by police. Where were the police when the White Trump supporters were out complaining about their "Freedoms". Nobody was kneeling on their necks.

2

Why not do both. You can protest very well today by writing letters , going on line, phoning. In fact you can make yourself a real pain to those responsible without even leaving you chair.

1

We must find a way to balance both. Protest with a mask and practice as much distancing as possible?
Also, keep washing those damn hands!! 🙂

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:504289
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.