Agnostic.com

11 1

What about this one: Virtually everything learned in school about Thanksgiving is a lie, including the central story of the feast celebrating a partnership between Native Americans and early European settlers. The Pilgrims were fanatical and violent religious zealots who considered indigenous Americans savages, and the Indians naturally resented their presence. The modern, feel-good story is propaganda that's only 120 years old, but there was a celebratory feast in Massachusetts in 1637 -- proclaimed by Gov. John Winthrop for the return of Puritan gunmen from hunting and murdering hundreds of Pequot Indians. from cheapism by andrew lisa?

Croebheir 6 Apr 23
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

11 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

Yup. It's all a lie, as is just about everything else anyone raised in the U.S. somewhere other than a rez has "learned" about native Americans. What's the question?

0

No surprises there.

0

History is a narrative written by the victors.
Truth isn't a consideration.

0

It is the repeating of history which is recognized when we know history is what makes being conscious about it important.

1

White history definitely whites out our terrorist acts on others and non white history of accomishments are erased.

1

Most of what is taught of history is propaganda conveniently skipping the unsavory parts. We put architects of genocide on our money, paying them homage for a job well done.

2

I am living in Plymouth and they have a sign "Americas First Thanksgiving" Growing up in Mass the emphisis was (I believe) to educate about the area. Lots of tourism too. There are many reasons for this post. I compare it to the religious fairytales that are part of holidays. Seems like every other weekend is some holiday to me. Thanks for the input folks. Croehbeir.

2

Whatever. I no longer enjoy celebrating it anymore, the food is no longer compatible with the way I live.

Same here

2

History is always written by the winners. When Legend gives way to truth, print the legend.
Quote from the movie The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance.

2

Yes, I knew this. I still enjoy a family get-together (with all the stupid family things that go on) with friends. I've met many Christians who try to make it a religious holiday. I'm very quick to point out what happened to the Native Americans in the area afterwards. While it has sad beginnings (and this should be known by Americans), it has changed over the years. I consider it an American Holiday, not a religious one. What our ancestors did the Native Americans was really bad, it should be remember and brought into the daylight.

1

Sorry, but I don't really care. It's ancient history.

marga Level 7 Apr 23, 2018

I think we should care, because the genocide our forefathers engaged in puts a huge black mark on our history as a nation purportedly built on democracy and freedom.

You should care. Would it be OK for Germans to celebrate Krystallnacht or the invasion of Poland or the building of Auschwitz in a few hundred years because by then it would be 'ancient history'?

@jperlow You can care for both of us. πŸ™‚

Ditto. I can’t repent for the sins of my forefathers. That falls on them and them alone.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:64611
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.