Agnostic.com

2 0

Is it wrong to pigeonhole people and judge them not according to their personal merits and actions, but according to the label of the pigeonhole?
Most people intuitively would say: of course that's wrong. That's what racism, sexism and other -isms are about: you belong to group X, therefore you are worthy or unworthy, morally superior or inferior etc...

That's exactly what liberals and progressives would have agreed upon two or three decades ago.
Then came the postmodern turn with its identity culture and politics.
Then came the ideology of intersectionality.

And now it's fashionable again to pigeonhole people and judge them according to the labels attached to those pigeonholes.
The whole world is divided into two main classes: what used to be the bourgeoisie versus the proletariat in Marxist doctrine has been replaced by the dichotomy "oppressed vs. oppressors".
Nobody can escape; you and me and everybody else is either an oppressor or an oppressed. And your personal deeds are totally irrelevant when it comes to putting you in one of these two groups.
The decision about on which side your are is made, just as it used to be in racism or sexism or homophobia, according to characteristics you did not choose and of which you have no control: your color of skin, your sex, your sexual orientation.

Are they serious? Do they really believe to build a better world by using the old categories, just inverting the moral hierarchy ? What used to be oppressed and despised 50 years ago is now celebrated and morally superior, and vice versa? Anybody with a modicum of common sense can see that the only effect of this revenge will be (and already is) a socio-cultural backlash; justice and injustice have just changed places and the moral hierarchy has been turned upside down, but the whole rotten structure is still in place, underpinned by self-righteousness and tribal instincts.

Matias 8 July 12
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

2 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

Personally, I pigeonhole "people who complain about losing white male privilege" as douches, but that might be wrong of me. They're probably just people of incredibly limited perspective who never developed empathy for anyone not of their tribe, and can't put themselves in the perspective of someone who has to go out every day and "prove" they "earned" their job, their house, their car (should they be so lucky as to have those things; millions don't).

Talking of "self-righteousness and tribal instincts," that's basically what complaining about equality comes down to; other people not of your tribe don't deserve to be up alongside you. I espouse post-tribalism; the only immoral and unjust thing is telling other people they should know their place and not ask for a chance at more, which is basically what your post comes across as.

When your neighbor calls the police because they think you look suspicious walking out of your own house, and you have to prove that you live there or risk getting handcuffed; then you can complain about "identity politics". The plain fact is that a lot of white people still discriminate and think they are the only ones who belong in "their" kind of neighborhood.

2

This seems to be a bit of hysteria. But for a very long time many people, primarily women and minorities, were treated very poorly and it was completely normal and acceptable to freely and publicly say degrading and bigoted comments about these people.

Now, people aren't so willing to be walked over and stepped on. People, especially minorities, push back against bigotry.

Maybe some people think they push back too hard and that makes people uncomfortable.

Maybe when women's rights aren't being taken away, when unarmed black people aren't being shot by police, when gays and trans people aren't being murdered... maybe then they'll stop pushing back so hard. Angry people aren't always completely fair. Shocking!

And sure, when people feel threatened they ban together into "tribes". That's nothing new.

You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:676379
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.