Agnostic.com

6 4

Regarding 'microaggressions', it is not important what you meant or what you said, but only how it was perceived, and if someone complains, it means that the aggression took place: there can be no false accusation. This is a source of endless conflict, especially in a society as diverse as ours. There is always someone to take offense at something.
It has reached the point where, when a harmless question such as "where are you from?" is addressed to a member of a minority group, the latter feels legitimate to respond aggressively, including with hate speech. This is not the kind of environment that promotes social harmony.

Thibaud70 7 May 10
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

6 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

But of course it was always possible for people to take offense through innocent misunderstanding and probably always will be. Where there is an addressable problem, it will be where people have been programmed by a sub-culture to see offense to an excess degree, and that is caused ultimately by wider social breakdown.

1

The speaker, any speaker, cannot have any idea what triggers the spoken-to person may have, that is LUDicrous IMO.....until we have telepathy, have good intentions when you speak and if someone reacts negatively, avoid them in futeure. Period.

Someone could be having a bad day and bring that baggage into the experience. If someone continues to react negatively then maybe reevaluate your interactions with them and decide to avoid. YMMV.

0

In my experience, people misinterpret silence as well, so you're damned if you do and damned if you don't.

2

There’s a distinction made between intent and impact. Unintended insult is a possibility. Faux pas happens. Problems with the concept of microaggressions are that it violates the principle of charity where the other person should try to interpret behaviors in the best possible light and that it makes people too self-conscious. Also microaggression as a concept could be a form of ableism. Some people are socially awkward by no fault of their own due to poor socialization, previous trauma, or being on the autism spectrum. And people may act out of ignorance of other cultural norms.

Microaggressions could still be a valuable concept but has become weaponized. I haven’t heard it discussed much in the past couple years.

1

Hmm... I committed a "microagression" yesterday, I think. I made a comment meant to be helpful, but it was taken as an insult and I made it even worse by talking more, when I should have either changed the subject, or just kept quiet. It was a social faux pas - not hate speech of any kind.

I should have started the conversation with my "go to" question which is to ask where the visitors are from. Normal question here, as most of the travelers are visiting from somewhere and it breaks the ice. I even ask where folks are from if they are speaking with an accent or in a foreign language.

I'm caucasian in a very ethnically diverse place, and so far people are proud to tell me where they are from and interesting things to do in their home town. They are usually asking me questions about my home, the place they are visiting.

But I get what you are saying -- seeing what is happening in other places.

2

Somewhere along the line confrontation became offensive. People don't get confronted anymore, only offended.

puff Level 8 May 10, 2023
Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:723367
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.