Agnostic.com

3 2

Southerners want to build statues to a civil war hero? Why not build one of George H. Thomas?

He was a Virginian who stayed loyal to the Union. Fought under Grant, won at Chattanooga and Nashville. Pioneered modern combined arms, logistics and intelligence and deployed and used repeating rifles better than anyone.

He won battles without butchering thousands of men like Grant and without burning down everybody's stuff in his path like Sherman. He swore an oath to defend the Constitution of the United States like Lee, but didn't break it to take up arms for people to be able to keep owning other people. And unlike Lee, he consistently won battles in offensive operations rather than hiding out in the fortifications around Richmond.

Oh. But he wasn't fighting to preserve chattle slavery. Which is the "cultural heritage" you're really crying about the loss off.

WittyBastard 4 May 23
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

3 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

The civil war hero statues were mainly built at a time when white southerners felt the need to reassert their privilege and status. This is the Jim Crow era, largely in the first half of the 20th century.

I think the statues are less about history and more about holding onto the "glorious" past.

That's why I don't understand the "erase history" argument. Statues don't change history. They commemorate something or someone. Why commemorate racists and traitors?

1

I any conflict there are Heros on both sides, to judge the worthyness of the title Hero is not our right. The views and values of our world and the views and values of the past world are not the same. You are against the idea of a Southern Hero why? is it because you believe that the Civil War was based upon Freedom? If that was true then why did the North wait two years after Davis surrenderd to free Northern Slaves? The Civil War like all war had nothing to do with Human Rights or Human dignity It was based on commerce. At the time the Southern slave owners had already realized that owning a person is expensive. Feeding, clothing, housing, and medical expenses no matter how poorly they are done still are expenses. To pay a person a low wage then let them pay for their own expenses is way more cost efficient. Now if you read some of the letters written by Lincoln to Davis at the begining of the civil war it's more apparhent that Lincoln's biggest concern was the Southern desire to sell their raw materials to Europeans that where willing to pay more for the Cotton, Tobacco and Corn that the South had. The Northern economy was more manufacturing based, without the raw materials provided by the South the North had nothing to manufacture. The war was about money not human rights all evidence supports this idea. Again if it was about human rights the Northern States would have freed their slaves before the war not two years after. So if the Southern Folks want to honor a man that stood for their right to profit as capitalists then big deal thats them. Personally I don't care either way just thought I would throw in another perspective, or angle to view this under. have a nice day and please don't flood me with hate mail for offering a different opinion, one that has historic merrit, and not personal belief.

@WittyBastard So You read The letters written by Lincoln? they are preserved for history too. But I guess they don't fit your outrage and hate, so they don't count. It's all the same to me either way. If you want to contnue the the cycle of hate and not look for ways to get over the past and move on, thats all you. Thanks for presenting the topic.

0

That's awesome! You should circulate a petition or something, and watch all those southerners freak out.

You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:88203
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.