Agnostic.com

12 4

Reincarnation

When clients ask about my own religious beliefs, I redirect by saying, "If there is reincarnation, I want to be rock." Invariable this seeming non-sequitur response defuses their question as everyone asks, "Why?" (as opposed to attacking or endorsing my belief). I respond that of things I need to learn, patience is fundamental. Being a rock would help with that. How do others respond? This a professional situation.

OzarkThinker 2 June 27
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

12 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

If anyone asks, and it doesn't happen often, I say I'm pagan. Not sure that shuts down any further questions.

0

I think that we as human beings are stuck in a reincarnation cycle till we have mastered life in every possible way here on this earth. When this has been accomplished we will be ready to become citizens of the universe and no restricted to this penal colony!

Sounds like a Hindu concept to me. Reincarnation implies some giant, celestially-managed PLAN...far too human-centric for me.

0

I believe in the force that created the universe. I just don't know whether it is sentient or not (laws of probability in a flat, infinite universe would be an adequate description for non sentient god)... or, I believe in god, not religion, is my response... but that's my beliefs and might not work for you.

0

If I may ask, what is your profession?

0

To stop existing. I get that.

3

Was checking in to a hospital for surgery , and a woman was filling in paperwork and asked , if I drink ( no ) , if I smoke (no) , if I do drugs (no) , did I have someone at home to help me after the surgery (no) , what's my religion ( atheist ) , She stopped writing , looked at me , then asked , " Well , what do you use for a crutch , when you need help ? " Lady , I just stand on my own two feet .

0

You give a response to that question FAR more importance than most people and you have good manners. In a professional situation, I'd smile sweetly, shake my head and say "Please, I never speak of my religion."

@JustKip How can anyone be ''too polite'' in this circumstance? In a professional situation, you behave professionally. It makes a good point.

0

My fave response so far is to shrug and say I'm really nothing, but sort of Christian-ish, Buddhist-ish.
Since most supposed Christians barely know anything about their own religion yet also do yoga, most seem taken aback, and just nod.

0

An aware worm would be a strange, but wonderfully short, life.

JacarC Level 8 June 27, 2018
1

I don't have to deal with it professionally, but my response is to say I don't know what it means to be reborn. What gets reborn? Your soul? What is that? Your memories? Even people who claim to have been reborn have only the vaguest recollection of past lives. Some essential self stripped of memories? I don't ask these things to be clever. I really don't know. I suspect the whole concept of reincarnation is poorly thought out, but I don't entirely discount its possibility given that the very concept of self is confusing and even mysterious.

Lalo Level 5 June 27, 2018
0

I'd rather be a star - a small mass one at that. Maybe a brown dwarf or just a little bit more so I could fuse H in my core and eventually graduate to being Helium Dwarf star when I died after living for 100's of billions of years.

1

I'm as general as I can be. I try to take into consideration the listener & find a common denominator to carry the subject & um absolutely as brief as possible.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:117399
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.