Possibly provide real life examples that have consequences and then point out that their religious belief requires they ignore consequences of not using evidence and logic. May not work right away but might get them to think .
Well...this is true to a point. The preachers tell the congregation that the bible is the truth and the way and they should believe everything thats in it. The preacher refers to scripture as evidence to what he's preaching. That's his truth, evidence, and logic. We know it's all bullshit, but because the congregation wants to follow this, our belief is not what they're wanting to accept. It's like @twshield says. Everyone has his own truth and logic.
Remember, when responding to arguments of a doggedly determined magical thinker-- aka a religious zealot-- we are not responding so much to change that zealot's mind, an exercise in futility, as we are to counter their potential influence over other audience who might be considering the merits of their sales pitch. We are arguing to deny them converts. It is well worth the effort.