Agnostic.com

14 2

The biggest difficulty I have as an atheist is that I am a teacher and have to deflect questions about my faith, just in case a zealous parent might get offended or concerned I will influence their child.

WhiteShark1964 4 June 11
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

14 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

Keep "dancin"... the more you dance the easier it becomes... when all else fails... lie.

Tomas Level 7 June 19, 2018
0

I think the proper answer is a version of "that's private, i do not discuss my beliefs"

0

This is a real problem. The fear of holding a belief. In some countries, you would be sentenced to death for holding some views. But even in a liberal country we are afraid of revealing our true nature due to fear of reprisal. How sad!!! I am lucky to live in a country where people are not persecuted for their views. So I can shout from the top of the roof that I do not have a religion and do not believe in any god without the fear of being hounded from my job. I don't know how I'll cope in a country where you have to hide your true feelings, views etc... just to fit in.

1

Why would your beliefs ever come up? If questioned, you can answer that the subject is personal and you don't feel the need to answer.

Deb57 Level 8 June 13, 2018
1

I was offered a teaching job a few years back, at a very strong Christian youth camp. I asked if my absence of belief would be an issue. They said as long as I thought the believe, attended prayers, sang hymns and never mentioned being an atheist I would be fine. They also said, many of the others wer atheists, just just have to keep it to themselves. I passed on the job.
Hell, tomorrow I assist the local food bank, which uses our community centre, I work bloody hard, but they don't want me to talk to the public because I am a heathen. Ha, fat chance, 1/2 the people there come to talk to me, I spend most of my time walking around supposedky gardening. People like to talk to the local nut.

4

Christian teachers have to do the same thing just in case there's an overzealous atheist parent. That's why teachers should just teach and keep their personal views on politics and religions to themselves.

at 63 back in college a teacher says something to me about religion I say I am an atheist. One teach talked like an atheist but said she believe in god and I said really? Some people just can't shake the religion their parents pushed on them!

@benhmiller Those are inappropriate conversations between teachers and students. Teachers should teach and not mix their teachings with their opinions, faith or lack thereof. That being said - I also don't agree with this idea that atheists have that religious parents pushed their religion on their kids. When parents find something that works for them and makes them happy it is natural to involve their kids simply because they want their kids to realize the same success and happiness that they have and are experiencing - it's not an evil or duplicitous thing. This theory applies to parents that raise their kids as vegans, hippies, atheists or Christians. The issue isn't so much how the kids are raised - the issue is how parents react when their kids follow a different path. When they show disappointment or disapproval their egos are involved and it becomes more about them than their children who should not be raised to be our carbon copies.

1

What you are doing is making a tough gig even tougher. With you in this struggle man.

2

The link below is a really good article citing cases on the subject. I think if you were for example Christian it falls under the establishment clause of endorsement of religion. But as you're an atheist I would love to see a ruling on it since those against atheism often decry using the First Amendment as protection for freedom of religion 'and freedom FROM religion'.

[freedomforuminstitute.org]

1

I'm a big proponent of separation of religion and government (church/state) I give you kudos/respect for your concern and interest towards your students' education. I think you are doing the right thing, you say that you teach world literature, and you are showing them a big part of world literature by educating your students about the bible.. it is literature. I also would suggest other holy books/texts for them to learn about..( Qur'an, Ḥadīth, The four Vedas, Upanishads, Bhramanas, Aranyakas and Bhagavad Gita make up the treasure of Sruti literature, the Torah, Septuagint) so many to choose from.. it's like human beings, as social creatures that have evolved through natural selection, found a social niche to cling to and base beliefs upon.. I say we need good, caring educators, that are seeking the best explanations that comport to our reality..

@Omen6Actual I totally agree with you on Islam.. I like how Sam Harris put it. "Right now, Islam is the motherlode of bad ideas" but I do believe education is the key

2

Don't you have a union to protect you and represent you if need be?

You are allowed to say you have no faith. That seems quite benign to me.

I presume these rabid parents would prefer that, over you being a Muslim or a Satanist.

You'd be surprised. I'm not a teacher, but witnessed firsthand a parent saying that he'd rather deal with a Muslim teacher than an atheist one - according to him, "At least the Muslim still has morals, even if he gets it wrong"

@Karnaph

I'm so sick of religion. It's like a cancer

@Ellatynemouth - Agreed, but if it wasn't religion, it'd be something else. Religion, ultimately, is just a tool that enables and justifies horrible behavior. The people are the problem

1

What kind of teacher are you?

I teach World Literature and, as the Bible is the most alluded to book in the world, I try to make sure students are aware of its cultural significance. The funny thing is most do not even recognize that many of the allusions.

@LimitedLight It comes in in Elie Wiesel's Night, and many other texts. I do cover a small chunk of "Inferno" and have a discussion about other cultures' versions of Hell.

1

Yes, that would be tough. How does the school want you to react to those questions? Also, do they know your views, and you theirs?

IzMark Level 4 June 11, 2018

I have had zero guidance, although I use the rule, I teach literature and if the Bible is referenced in a text, then I speak about the Bible as literature. When students ask about my faith, I tell them that I do not discuss my personal religious beliefs in class.

3

That is a small price to pay for the important freedom. As a former high school teacher, I was glad to just not discuss religion in any way.

3

Yes I can sympathize it's got to be a virtual mine field.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:104614
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.