Agnostic.com

8 0

Is playing Dungeons and Dragons harmful to young people as it encourages acknowledgement of deities?

Geoffrey51 8 June 11
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

8 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

D&D teaches lots of good and useful things. Bookkeeping, social skills, basic math skills, even responsibility and comradeship.

It's simply make believe with some rules thrown in to aid fair evaluation of conflicts. (in game)

Some people have difficulty separating fantasy from real life, and that has nothing to do with D&D.

arnies Level 7 June 12, 2018

Agreed

1

Was playing Candyland harmful because it depicted sweets? What is with all the censureship?

0

It depends on your DM

1

It's easy to over rationalize the impact of games like D&D. I started playing D&D in 1975, three years after it came out. I continued to play it until around 1986 (sorry I'm a nerd). We had 2 engineers, an archaeologist (me) and a geologist in our campaign. What it did for us is stimulate our creativity, challenge our design skills, and gave us an us an appreciation and practice in problem solving. This early interactive game is not to be mistaken with the video version.
To your question, I do not think that D&D (non-video version only) dies not necessarily cause children to suddenly become deified. Nothing wrong with learning about other cultures, they are real and are vibrant, even if we do not buy into their paradigm.

t1nick Level 8 June 11, 2018

Excellent that it gave an extra dimension to your careers...and no half Orc is going to make md think otherwise.

0

No, that’s not why it’s harmful.

Is D&D harmful?

@Geoffrey51 yes.

Why do you feel it is harmful?

@arnies Atheistic characters have no power within the game, it promotes the idea that it is only through deities that any progress can be made. That said, I was kidding... but, I never had an interest in the game simply because I never knew anyone that played it that was not so overly consumed with it that it began to look like a cult with a nerd factor that pinned the needle.

2

That's no more a valid concern than fundamentalists saying it's harmful to play because it opens you up to evil spirits or "gives place" to the devil.

I have known a couple of players, including one that does it the old fashioned way, from books (no computers). They do not believe in deities. A fundamentalist would probably say that's because they play the game.

D&D is like any other immersive role-playing game, it's harmful only if it becomes an addiction that reduces your ability to cope with Real Life.

Agreed. Develops creativity for both the DM and the players.

Agreed. Develops creativity for both the DM and the players.

0

Im 66 and used to play D&D over 30 years ago and more,1979 its fantasy, before we had computer games,,,,

Me too! I've been playing D&D online for a few months. Still as enthralling as ever

0

My atheist nephew plays smite.

I think you're safe from belief in deities when mythology becomes a source of entertainment. I played D&D from the time I was about eleven until I was almost thirty. I didn't believe in the deities in the game any more than I did the demons, monsters, undead, or magic spells.

Come to think of it; I think putting deities in that context may benefit the development of skepticism.

JimG Level 8 June 11, 2018
Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:104909
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.