Agnostic.com

6 1

Is there such a thing as universal values, that all cultures share?

OrangeJuice 6 June 20
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

6 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0
0

I have been all over the world, and even as a kid, I was impressed that most cultures really do want the same things...after the basic needs of shelter, food, water, etc., they all want something better for their children...the golden rule seems to also be predominant, though said in different ways...pretty much, people want to be left alone to figure out, in their own way, why they are here and how they can make the best of it...being a human and understanding what that means was often a topic of discussion no matter where I was.

0

No, you may think you have such high morals and that they are so obvious that naturally all would agree, but there are cultures that would cut your head off for them. Anyone that would behead me for not believing what they believe clearly does not hold the same values. I also don’t share the same values as many Republicans. So, what makes me think I’m right? As an example, the fact that I don’t want my head cut off leads me to believe that other people don’t want their head cut off... If you want to cut someone’s head off and still don’t want your head cut off my morals are better. Did I overplay the beheading example?

0

Perennial Philosophy by Aldous Huxley. He argues yes.

That’s an interesting book. I’m not quite so sure all religions share an esoteric similarity as he argues. I should look through that book again.

0

They vary depending on culture

Marine Level 8 June 20, 2018
0

Not that exist "out there" for everyone to stub their toe on, exactly, but there are some harms that are so universally clear and present dangers to society that virtually all societies share similar convictions about them. Things like murder outside of the context of war or self defense, child neglect or exploitation, and rape are either universally forbidden or at least those governments who allow them in some form, show consciousness of guilt in doing so, by attempting to hide or cover up such activities, and generally by maintaining a facade of being against them.

Societal morality is all about generally agreed-upon harms and how to discourage them from happening. Some harms are more ambiguous or disputed or depend on how you frame the conversation about it. And what's considered universal today (e.g., slavery is a great harm and a gross violation of civil rights) wasn't accepted at all, say, a couple hundred years ago. Or ... it was only accepted for white people or white men or wealthy white men or whatever, rather than for all.

So morality evolves, too.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:111339
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.