Agnostic.com

11 3

Is religious belief weird? And do people have religious beliefs because the beliefs are emotionally satisfying despite the fact that the religious belief is inconsistent with the persons other beliefs?

See the great article in Psychology Today [psychologytoday.com]

This might help explain the weird beliefs like: the Sandy Hook shooting deniers, climate change deniers, that Barak Obama is a Muslim, that the holocaust never happened and cargo cults among many others.

AwarenessNow 8 June 29
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

11 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

I find religion strange. It’s like believing in crystal balls and other such supernatural stuff. But each to his own. Maybe our brains are wired differently.

Livia Level 6 June 29, 2018
4

It's not weird. Intelligent people accept there's no meaning to life. We get old and die, just like any other living thing. And there is often suffering in between. Being born into a war zone or poverty would be the worst case scenario. Life can be brutal and bleak.

So religion seems a very human type response. It's a comforting delusion which gets the weak minded through the journey. An almost evolutionary adaptation for survival.

Unfortunately, religion is still a delusion.

0

I think some people definitely want a path laid out for them and to live forever. People fear the unknown...all of us do to certain degree and religion provides answers to questions science can't yet or doesn't convince people yet. I don't think religion is a "bad" thing in itself giving people a pretty solid ideal to work towards. Implementation of any theory is riddled with all kinds of people that take advantage so I don't really t hold that against "religions". I mean take a Communist or Capitalist theory of govt...both work perfectly in theory but neither really work very well in practice. Some people are still more driven by greed than any belief/ideology can contain...doesn't mean everyone is bad
I believe most people in most religions are trying to do what most non-religious are...just be good people and get better everyday. How we choose to get there shouldn't make a bit of difference.

There’s no perfect system, that’s true, but any idea which can be used to justify hatred and exclusion is not one I can sanction. That includes Capitalism and Communism.

4

You must begin with the realization that human beings are not "rational" creatures. The part of the brain that does the heavy lifting for symbolic thought arrived late in the evolutionary day and is very much subservient to its predecessor "brain stem" neurons. Simply put, human behavior is primarily emotionally driven. Each culture programs those emotions in a particular way. The mega-culture on the planet at the moment includes elements that we classify as "religious". Those elements are "super natural" i.e. things not part of physical reality. Hence they are immune to physical evidence or "reason" ( a fairly recent invention of our species). It is all atavistic, i.e. left-overs from our past. In practice, it is cognitively dissonant for believers to examine their dogma since it cannot be reconciled with empirical experience. That dissonance is directly in proportion to the degree to which the individual is programmed in the mega-culture's super-naturalism. The good news is that in the developed world (Europe, Japen, etc) that programming grows weaker and weaker and is function gone in much of it. The bad news is that in the United States it is woven in pretty deeply and is fully integrated with the ruling mechanisms. So, all we can do is strive to teach our children the elements of the post-enlightenment world-view and wait for the US to catch up with the world in its cultural development in this area. Slim hope though it might be.

Great post.

0

The vast majority of people believe in a religion. I define the term "weird" as "unusual, often with a negative implication". I don't think you can can consider unusual when it's the vast majority of people

Of course you can. Being a majority has nothing to do with unusual.

@jlynn37
Then what does the word “unusual” mean?

1

The vast majority of people believe in a religion. I define the term "weird" as "unusual, often with a negative implication". I don't think you can can consider unusual when it's the vast majority of people

0

Who knows why people believe what they believe?

0

I suppose those who believe these things don’t think that they are weird. I sometimes think that people who believe fervently in something like a deity cannot accept any criticism of it because it will chip away at their belief and that would make them confront the fact that they could be wrong. They can't allow any doubt to creep into their thinking because it could topple the whole edifice. It is much more comfortable to pedal conspiracy theories and be in denial.

4

Religion is delusion, pure and simple. Maybe a happy one for the believers, but still, total delusion.

Absolutely true.

3

I have a friend who is an 81 year old retired psychoanalyst. He has done a lot of research on the subject and he told me that humans, as far back as can be studied, have always had an innate need to worship something. It is apparently in our genes to worship something and there have been those among us who were fortunate enough to convince the majority of the rest of us to pay for the privilege.

Yes, I believe that is so. Primitive man worshipped the Sun, which to my mind is a far more logical thing to worship as without it we could not survive. The Romans, Greeks and Egyptians worshipped a variety of deities and gods, but it was only when the monotheist religions appeared that we started persecuting those who disbelieved. The Jewish god of the Old Testament who was invented by man has been a scourge on mankind ever since.

I agree. I sometime feel the need to thank someone or something for the fantastic life I have lived, but there is no one or nothing to thank but life itself.

@jlynn37 Being thankful and/or grateful is probably valid because if you are happy, regardless of the circumstances, you are among the fortunate. It is the fools who take pride in their good fortune that get on my nerves as they seem to think that they chose the genes and the environment that made them who and what he or she is and how they perceive his or her reality.

@Marionville I believe the Jewish idea of one God came before the Egyptians. Hence the Jews being Egyptian slaves. It began to grow after the Roman occupation of their land and Constantine converted.

@rainmanjr Thanks for your reply, however I think you are mistaken I believe the Egyptians go back as far as 3400 bc wheras Judaism is from around 2000 which is quite a bit later. This is why the Old Testament is such a lot of nonsense, because the world and it’s civiilisations are much older than this Jewish book of fables.

4

I am of the personal opinion that many religious people are counting on getting into heaven no matter what atrocities they commit in life, based only on their status as believers. It's also my belief that religion is by and large the biggest con in the history of humankind.

I agree and all one has to do is say the words "I believe" and that is their ticket to paradise.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:118564
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.