Agnostic.com

47 4

Did anyone suffer from depression or PTSD once leaving religion and deciding God wasn't real?

Jama765 7 July 10
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

47 comments (26 - 47)

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

I don't know if I would classify what I experienced as either depression or PTSD, but certainly there was a period of mourning, accompanied by all the associated feelings and stages.

0

No, I have not felt that. It dose not have to be "all or nothing" or "black or white". I have felt a spiritual connection since I was a little girl and never really conformed or felt any kind of commitment to religion. I have had near death experiences and out of body experiences, so yes i believe in an after life of sorts.

0

The emotional and psychological discomfort and pain legitimately feel the way through cognitive dissonance making our Exodus from faith mythical thinking to logic and reason quite real sometime very profound.
But it should not be confused with PTSD or clinical depression as they are rooted in different causes.
Education and understanding of new things created by the synapses in our brain are like muscles that we have never exercise and are similar can feeling the same pains after work the reaping the healthy benefits in the long run.
But you must be of good cheer for they're Millions around here and ever increasing numbers in our country that are making the same Exodus from imaginary thinking to critical thinking, reason and discovering the awe of seeing this world for what it is and being free from unethical and immoral fears unjustified by those who wish to use myths and legends to control you

0

my apologies for the choppy word salad from using voice recognition and lazy post editing while driving.
It's completely natural for us to become saddened and even depressed when discovering new things and being unable to socialize or have our friends and family relate our new learning curve.
After decades of research and new discoveries I still find myself saddened by being unable to relate the others the joys of new insights and discovery

1

The hardest part about leaving religion is that humans are social animals that evolved in groups for safety and security. Leaving a group, or losing your place in a group is a major life change and goes against our animal instincts to stay with the group.

Thus, most of your depression can be lifted by findign another group where you are welcome and accepted for who you are. Or, you could go on and boild a life where you are atonomous and dont' need others to fee secure. That takes much longer and a lot more effort.

For quick fixes, to fulfill social needs, in group interactions, meetup.com is a place tolook for people with similar interests, including agnostic/atheist groups.

Anyway, it is important to identify that your depression is is mostly caused by your loss of place within the group you left. Once you know the problemit is easier to find a workable solution to remedy the problem.

2

I was never really part of any religion, moving around the world I had different religious majorities surrounding me.. but there has been times I couldn’t help but wonder “would I be accepted more by the society if I was part of a religious group? Would I be less lonely?” Not the fact that -I no longer had the help/healing of prayers-.. I mean I’ve been getting shit done on my own as long as I can remember, I never feel the absence of an invisible helper 🙂 but at times I feel like I’m discriminated because I don’t hide my identity, and the fact people who were once surrounding me would vanish after they “find out” does hurt every now and then.

1

No, but l did stay in a Holiday Inn. That line is like "That's what she said," it works for so many things. ?

4

Hell no! It was a huge weight off my shoulders. I felt alive.

0

I suffer from depression which began in my childhood, because my entire family, most of all my mother, drank the Southern Baptist koolaid. I've never suffered from becoming agnostic.

I suffer from depression from being governed by good people that believe 100% in the tooth fairy
depression may be more common than people want to admit - stigma and all
its good to talk about it without having to pay a price

2

Quite the opposite. My depression all but disappeared when I let go of the idea of there being some master plan that was in charge of my life.

1

I grew up as a presbyterian - was a fanatic as a teen as I was trying understand my dysfunctional family's behaviors/government/society's behavior, etc. Kept noticing the contradictions and got into many arguments with a lot of people through out the years. Took some Philosophy of Religion classed and met a lot of agnostics/atheists along the way. When I finally dropped religion in my 30's - I went into a panic mode because I was so used to praying to god. It took me several years to get used to not praying. Finally over the years, I noticed some conflicting information and switched to Scientific Pantheist. Felt much better once I embraced this as it validated my inner promptings/observation of life. It is a real "loss" of identity & "support system" and it's confusing and scary for some people with a dramatic change of "lifestyle" or mentality. I felt very alone. I wasn't depressed but panicky as I felt I lost a "friend" but learned I need a compassionate living breathing sane human friends for real moral support.

2

Quite the opposite.

2

I just became angry at being lied to for so long. Then I became angry at people who can't or won't see the lies and come to the truth that is science.

1

Perhaps a little despondent, but I wouldn't be too quick to label it as depression.

Didn't last too long. A few months of pondering reality and the lack of a god.

0
1

Yes. I had to take depression medicine for a while, for the first time in my life. I went through a tailspin phrase, for sure.

I'm going thru several stages. It is tough, but I know ill be better once I heal..

1

I deff think stress. Family issues, long time friends....raising a child with a mother that is a barely functioning/educated Catholic. I think it was too gradual for me to be trama. Maybe if I were younger when it happened.

1

I received a PTSD diagnosis yesterday. I'm still digesting it. When I went back over everything, I think it may be something called CPTSD and it may be in fact from how hard it as to leave religion

What I've learns is what is called Raligious trauma syndrome. Look it up.

0

It's hard leaving things sometimes even if you've decided you don't believe

1

Absolutely NOT. I felt totally liberated. I was suicidal towards the end of my religious period, due to the bullying that I was dealing with in high school. Becoming atheist helped me get past that. I figured out that god wasn't going to do anything about it and it was up to me to figure out how to escape from my first hs and improve my life. At that time, a classmate who I actually considered to be nice died in a car crash; and, I recall thinking that if I was to commit suicide that the jerks I hated there would be celebrating and the people who cared would be upset. I left religion never turning back! It was the best decision I've ever made!

0

Sorry for everyone who has gone through this.

I was never religious, so this PTSD via religion is another reason just how bad worshipping is for people and society.

1

I feel free and happy.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:127907
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.