Agnostic.com

8 1

Yes, indeed.

Reignmond 7 Sep 13
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

8 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

Even as a devout Christian I found the book of Job ludicrous.
An all loving, all righteous God makes a BET with the Devil, allowing him to physically and psychologically torture an innocent man, to the point a despair and sickness, in order to prove that the man will not turn on his torturer.
He allows the Devil to KILL Job's entire family, ruin his life and render him to be wracked in pain and sickness.
BUT because Job is still a slave to his fear of god at the end of all this, god gives him a new wife and family, cures him and gives back his possessions, so that's all right then...Except for the people who are dead for the sake of this little ego trip.
It is the epitome of deviant scriptural evil, utterly disgusting.

0

To be honest, when I was a Christian, I saw this as simply a metaphor for being a mere mortal. I suppose my mind just rejected the notion that women are unclean as so ridiculous, that I had to come up with some other interpretation.

To be fair (and no, I don't know why I bother), the Bible also says that sin came into the world by one MAN (Romans 5:12). So it spreads the shame and blame around equally in that sense, I guess.

More broadly the whole notion that sin is a thing-in-itself somehow rooted in the physical world and particularly in our bodies -- this "stain of sin" that we'll never fully get rid of apart from death -- is the thread of Christian asceticism that runs through scripture. The disgust is not solely for women, it is for physicality and biology itself. We are filthy with sin, therefore, anything that physically proceeds out of one's body is an opportunity for self-loathing since it's symbolic of the stain of sin. Where women come into it is that the Bible was written by men, so they would of course focus on those biological products associated with pesky women, who also caused the fall by convincing Adam to eat from the forbidden tree, etc.

1

I have always felt it was odd that with such lines in the bible, that are very anti-women, that women are more likely to be and more strongly Christian than men.

Stockholm syndrome?

2

They say , you're clean if you're washed in the blood of Christ . So why aren't you clean from being washed in the blood of your Mom , as you're being born ?

WTF is it with Blood and cannibalism in Christianity?

1

Life is a box of chocolates.

Forrest Gump

0

I understand that among the Jewish believers, the book of Job is the most controversial. The idea that god would burden and plague a man to that extent just to win a wager, has always been a moral problem for thinking people.

Just like the rest of the bible it is all fairy tales and myths.

I did notice that the subtext of the scripture above is demeaning to women, by implying that women are by nature unclean. I hope that wasn't the point you intended to make with the post.

The point was that in the Abrahamic faiths women are thought to be unclean and less worthy than a man.

@Reignmond The note "Yes, indeed" posted algng with the meme could be taken as support of what the Meme says.

@snytiger6 It was a provacation, rather like "rattling the monkey cage".

0

We invented soap since then.

2

??? Why are you quoting the Bible. It's not even true, so why bother.

Then why study mythology?

@Reignmond That meme isn't presenting the quote as mythology..more like condemnation and misogyny.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:177934
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.