Agnostic.com

3 0

I was wondering what everyone thought of religion and religious people in the science fields.
Obviously, we all hear about the relatively high amount of atheists in the science field which mostly seem to stem from this 2009 study.
[pewforum.org]
They survey defined "scientists" as members of the American Assiciation for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) and found that 41% of the members were not religious at all compared to 4% of the general public in the US. While I'm the only person at the lab I'm currently working in that's religious, we do have some good diversity and religion rarely comes up (I only found out this year that my research advisor is a Muslim when I heard he had to takw time off to travel to a Houston Mosque).
I've tried finding surveys to find if that differed at all for people in veterinary as that's my field of interest, but was unsuccessful as most demographic surveys by the AVMA don't mention religion instead focusing on other things (gender, race, etc). Based on my own personal experience, I'd say the vast majority in the US are religious since most clinics have some kind of religious symbolism (eg Christian music on the radio).
I haven't had nearly enough experience in human hospitals to make a statement on their demographics, so I'd love to hear if anyone's had experiences they can share.
And of course, stay fabulous.

thezekroman 5 Sep 22
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

3 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

Tom Stoppard is my absolute favorite playwright. He is a wordsmith unlike anyone else. He wrote a play called the hard problem analyzing the very thing you question. I was fortunate enough to hear him speak with a physicist he spoke with in length to get to core of this hard 'problem'. The play only scratches the surface of an answer. When i walked in to the theatre i was starstruck at this man who changed the person i am. (I am better because his words encouraged mine) And i watched this man sit googly eyed over the words of a physicist. He was starstruck - so cute! By association, the physicist had credibility. I was taking in lal his words. But it wasn't his words that causedmore questions to spin. I thought surely my stoppard is an atheist, right?? Negative. I walked out of that disussion questioning the depth of his spiritually. Somewhere in the discussion, there was a statistic around 35% of scientists (in a closed study) subscribed to an atheist belief system. Another 40% to agnosticism. Thats terribly low (in my opinion). I think your post (and forgive me if i got this wrong) ... I think your post is asking if the numbers seem right. If the world is clearly science vs. faith, then one needs to pick a side. But, its not as simple as that. It seems to be a hard problem.

More or less. I was More so asking for people's experiences, especially if I get a sense as to how it would differ in a medical setting as it's clearly very different than a lab

1

there are no legitimate religionists in the science fields. there are certainly people who follow a religion. they keep it to themselves and don't try to skew scientific findings to support their religions, as a religionist would.

g

1

The more people do science the better. As long as they can separate the science and their personal belief I don't see how it would make any difference. So yeah, stay fabulous 🙂

Dietl Level 7 Sep 22, 2018
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:184767
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.