Agnostic.com

4 0

Why did they write all the outlandish stories and called them miracles in the bible? Did they think ppl would have remained illiterate like they were forever?

Greenheart 7 Oct 28
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

4 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

there is no unified "they" planning all sorts of control stuff and chuckling about illiteracy. people wrote what they perceived, what they speculated, what they thought MIGHT have happened, what they heard from people who heard from people who heard had happened. it got compiled and jumbled and much later got organized and edited, and yeah, those organizers and editors had political power on their minds, but that's not what was likely happening when the bible got written, piece by piece, by many people, over the course of time. it was part history (as it was understood at the time), part legend, part rulebook, part birth record (all those begattings are so boring, they HAVE to be based on something! no one would include them for effect!) most of this was probably purveyed orally long before anything got written down. it's a ridiculous book for modern people to take literally, and the rules and advice in it are not universally good either, but it was not likely to have been concocted with some horrible control plot in mind.

g

1

There are modern day cults whose followers believe equally crazy shit.. People are apparently very, very vulnerable ..or in need of concepts beyond reality… They refuse to admit such garbage isn’t true. Is reality really that painful?

Varn Level 8 Oct 28, 2018
0

They were all meant to be allegorical. The older stories were edited by fifth century BCE scribes who added well known symbols and symbolic numbers to insure there was no misunderstanding. It worked for a while. The problem is that if you don't want to spend a great deal of time decoding them all, you're better off not reading it at all. If you are going to listen to others talk about it make sure they're an atheist bible scholar or that at least a person who understands the symbols. Not too many people want to work that hard these days. I do though. I think the truth is fascinating, that includes knowing why people tell lies about the bible's actual meaning.

R there really codes in miracles. On what basis do u interpret them. Isn't the bible should b read literally.

I never said anything about secret or magical. They just indicated that the story was allegorical. Most of the meanings look like they show Greek influence. Plato lived and wrote about the time the O.T. was compiled. I believe most of the symbolism actually came from Babylon. Ezekiel's dream, for example, was just astrology symbols, easy to figure out. Philo of Alexandria proved that the O.T. was 85% consistent with what the Greek philosophers thought was natural law. Paul's legitimate seven Epistles corrected Judaism to make it 100% compliant with the Greek Stoics School in Tarsus. There were forged letters from Seneca to Paul sold on the antiquities market About 100 years ago. By The Way this info came from Yale. Free lectures on YouTube.

1

No one knows. What’s done is done. Just give it a sideways glance in passing and move to something better.

Speaking of miracles, reality with conscious life is a profound, amazing miracle a thousand times more noteworthy than any puny little miracle in the Bible.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:210683
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.