Agnostic.com

8 12

When in defence of religion, people say ‘Well the church does a lot of good’ but is it not like a lawyer saying ‘Yes, my client robbed a few banks and killed a few people but he bought his parents some very nice presents and was very generous to his friends’...

RichieO 8 Jan 10
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

8 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

What is good and bad and for whom is it good and bad?

0

Xians don't do anything that secularists don't do and non-believers do it without trying to spread all that Jebus shit around.

XIAN
"Thank you for helping me find my lost dog."
"You're welcome. That good Lord above guided us in the right direction. Have you heard the Word of the Lord?"

SECULAR
"Thank you for helping me find my lost dog."
"You're welcome."

0

Which church? Some of ‘em do good things IMO.

3

Yes. Religion does a lot of good merely because it's ubiquitous and a primary platform for belonging and community. Some people and some communities do a lot of good, sometimes more good than harm. Others do not.

It's also the same thing as a tobacco company pointing to its charitable giving or an exploitive diamond mine pointing to the joy of all the young ladies gifted with their wares.

You had to go and mention tobacco.

Now I want a cigarette...

1

Yep. All the charitable works in the world aren't going to make the skeletons in the closet go away. Until the church addresses it's own issues, they'll all just sit there festering like an infected, untreated ass boil.

2

The answer is simply.
Even if the churches did only good, awesome, moral etc things.
This does not prove god is real.
You can have a club of people doing good things that does not claim some unveriafiable truth...

Religion is based on a false premise -- the existence of supernatural beings and realms, supported by the failed epistemology of religious faith -- and so cannot help but be harmful to the brains of billions of people. Any good done in the midst of that is just window dressing.

1

It's one of the worst defences of religion I hear. Churches "do a lot of good." I retort sharply: "Well then, do genuine good, spare us the Bronze Age mumbo jumbo, and clean up your act." It's pointless of course. The "good" is a ruse, a cover. Reminds me of gangsters like Al Capone, who used to give money to the poor and help people, letting everyone know it. All the time he was peddling bad booze, running brothels and protection rackets, not to mention murder to the point of mass slaughter. Won't do.

Doing 'good' as an act in and of itself easily and often becomes identified with the belief(s) of the person, group or organization that did something that is deemed good. Perhaps I am missing something but I am of the opinion that there is no need to attribute 'good' to any particular religion or political belief system. There is no need for any individual, religious or political organization to highlight their act as good, it somehow detracts from the act. Many good acts have been carried out by people who have remained anonymous.

Good acts may spring from questionable intentions that fuel the accumulation of Brownie points which may cause some people to believe that such and such person who carried out atrocities has some redeeming features

@ASTRALMAX yes, I should have added to my comment that I don't believe Churches do good, but that individuals in them may do good things because they are good people. I've noticed however that even then it's all about spreading their religious nonsense. Everything they do is to that end. I've also noticed that churches will do bandage good things, like charity, but fundamental reform and solutions, never.

@David1955 Bertrand Russell more or less said the same about reform within the Catholic Church when he said that no self respecting physicist today would hold and maintain the views of Issac Newton but the Catholic Church has not changed its postion since the Council of Nicaea.

0

There is no acceptable rationale for pedophilia.....the church should pull its head out of its collective ass and start ex communicating any priest that is proven to engage in those practices. Should be a zero-tolerance policy....

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:262432
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.