I'm thinking you posted on humanist but tried to read on agnostic, or visa versa. I'm still trying to figure out how those two sites feed into each other. But I think it's really one database, with two portals. Your permissions on each portal are different (uness you accept the default settings) PLUS if you were responding to someone else's thread who has different settings for each portal, the way you will see their posts, is different on each site. They "own" their posts, so theirmsettings override yours.