Agnostic.com

12 2

Today is Saturday. Since I work in the the grocery retail industry, I call this particular day the Saturday From Hell. It's the single day (at least here in Manitoba) wherein the grocery stores are open in between good Friday and Easter Sunday. As such, it tends to be busy to point of being in direct competition with Christmas Eve.

Yes, despite the fact that this happens EVERY year, people still panic due to not having a store for 48 hours out of a weekend. As in every holiday. Don't even get me started . . .

But, this all got me thinking. Particularly when I run across an article in which some grocers over in Winnipeg were being forced to remain closed yesterday or face a nasty fine (potentially $10,000).

[cbc.ca]

It made me wonder, is this right? Or more, is this something we ought be still doing in this day and age?

On one hand, we know why these rules were enacted in the first place. Both Sunday shopping and holiday retail restrictions are inherently based in theistic roots.
Also keep in mind that Remembrance Day (Veterans Day for the stateside majority reading this) here in Canada is but a retail half day. Everything is open and unrestricted after 1pm.

Yes. Jesus gets 1, veterans get half.

But on the other hand, restricted hours/closings on Sundays/Holidays could be argued to enable people to have at least one day in which to spend with family and friends.

For those that don't have the active social dynamics of the other group, however, an open business may represent a reprieve from what would otherwise be a potentially tedious experience. A chance to keep the mind occupied (or make some money!).

So, when it comes to restricted hours on holidays, what is your opinion?

Good?
Obsolete?
Something Else?

Mb_Man 7 Apr 20
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

12 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

love a long weekend but if the point is to go to church and pay due to the Invisible Man in the Sky . . . I'd rather be at the office. At least that has a purpose

2

When I was younger (1,000,000 years ago), stores in Chicago weren't open on holidays. Most stores were closed on Sunday -- not all restaurants, but a good percentage of them. As time has passed, almost everything is open on Sunday -- except Chik-Fil-A. I also noticed that if the board of directors was predominantly Christian (a total guess on my part), the Christian holidays were honored; if not Christian, then not so much. My personal 2 cents -- the large crowds indicate greed and avarice.

1

Closing on part this weekend gives people in retail to spend time with there families no matter what there belief system is. Some retail chains run there people raged, because they don't give a damn there people or families.

@TCorCM Yes< I mean't they don't.

1

I vote for letting business decide. If your true to your beliefs you would be voting with your wallets.

1

It should be up to the business.

1

Businesses should do what is good for their business. If the majority of their community and employees are religious, it might be better business to close, lest the public see them as "anti" religion and all the employees call in sick to get out of working holidays. Likewise, it might be good business to stay open. It should be their choice. There shouldn't be a law mandating losing business for religion.

0

Obsolete. Business should no longer be restricted on days or hours. Owners should be able to decide for their own business though. Most US businesses are still impacted as in most areas. Sunday hours don't
begin until Noon (excepting major grocery chains). In my opinion, this is still because of religion, as most services are in the AM.

2

What do you say to a Muslim on Christmas day? "A pint of milk and a packet of cigarette papers please"
I remember when all Sundays were like this. Pubs shut till 7.00 pm. TV much the same except for religious programs. Shops shut and only the radio for entertainment. Which with the exception of "pick of the pops" was a almost as dire as the TV.
People wonder why in such a now secular society as the UK is, I am so anti religion. It is the memory of all those interminable Sundays

0

I grew up in the Peg. I remember grocery stores could only sell essentials on Sunday... eventually they were open as full service.
It’s pretty ridiculous considering Canada is a more secular country.
Here they are open every day except Christmas. My local grocery store is open 6am-midnight.

People who advocate closed stores on Sundays do it for religious reasons only. If you want to spend time with family, don’t shop. I do a lot of shopping on Sundays as do many... it’s always packed.

1

That sounds much more restrictive than in the US...or at least where I live, which is a very conservative area anyway. Retailers are all mostly open as far as I known. The only day where virtually everything shuts down is Christmas. I know of a handful of businesses that are closed on Sunday near me--a couple of restaurants, Hobby Lobby, a mobile home retailer. I'm sure a few more close on Easter, but I'm not aware of any. All the grocery stores are certainly open normal hours.

(As an aside, I'll never forget the Saturday before US Thanksgiving in 1996. It was my first day as a cashier, and I was on check stand 16 in a store that had only 16 registers. It was as if the store had been overrun. I hated working retail.)

1

If you are working for someone who doesn't give you a few days a week off you shouldn't work there.

If you are an employer you shouldn't overwork your employees because they might go crazy and then anything could happen, moral is important too.

1

There should be no restrictions to business based on anyone's religious beliefs.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:334415
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.