Agnostic.com

4 3

"Not pro-life, not pro-choice, no-choice"
Worse Than Abortion? (The Bible Wins Again)
[patheos.com]

OldMetalHead 9 Aug 30
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

4 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

The bible is full of dead babies and children. Moses alone racked up a terrible bodycount. it's laughable that the religious try to spin it so "god hates abortion" and "all life is sacred".

0

Personally, I absolutely believe it is a personal choice made by oneself or with the family. Certainly, not a choice made by the church and especially not elected officials. I was reading some sections of the Talmud. It was and I think still is (to a point) believed by the Jewish leaders that there are 3 stages of existence: (1) embryo - a sack of liquid cells akin to a cyst (2) Fetus - cells being literally a part of a woman's body, not a separate entity. (3) Human - birth or being outside of the woman's body. So, I understand, as far as they are concerned, if a woman's life is at stake, abort...if a fetus is found to have a disease or be malformed in some way...the perceived cyst can be aborted, if so desired. But once in labor or in delivery, then the fetus is considered "human" but without a soul, until life is breathed into it...then abortion is not allowed - So at that point, the "thou shall not kill" comes into play. Um, maybe that is why it is #6 on the list of do's and do not's.

I'm not Jewish, but it's my understanding that the Talmud states that the new life begins AFTER birth when the baby takes its first breath.

@BitFlipper Yes, you are right and that is what I wrote...but agreed I did not make clear the part once in labor or in delivery...there are extreme cases a pause on that thought is taken. It gave an example that if a pregnant woman is being executed by law the jailers do not have to wait for the birth to execute the woman...however, if the fetus is moving down the birth canal (ie as in last stage labor) - they will give it time to be born, then execute the woman. When the head has come out then and only then is it considered an actual "person or nefesh". At that point, the baby cannot e harmed.

@Maximai makes sense to me.

3

When, Oh when are religions going keep they filthy fingers out of the Productive Organs of women and let THEM choose what happens to and within THEIR OWN bodies?

3

The Bible has all sorts of ridiculous stories and rules that most people have never heard. It’s why reading the Bible from cover to cover will make most people atheists!

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:395694
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.