Agnostic.com

1 1

I found this video from Vsauce about the future of reasoning to be a pretty chilling indictment of modern society and the impact of social media on it.

Discuss

prometheus 7 May 2
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

1 comment

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

0

When you start from a false premise you can never reach a sound conclusion.
The mind does not use the brain as a tool, the "mind" is a name given to the perceived functioning of the brain by those who did not understand the human body millennia ago.
MInd is an abstract concept with no more reality than the number 2, we know what it means, but what it described has no physical presence, it is merely a function.
Therefore when this guy begins with the false premise that the mind is a thing separate from physicality, any theory he builds upon that is invariably wrong and worthless.

The point is that take your brain, put it in an isolation / sensory deprivation chamber and your "mind" functions are entirely limited to the physicality of your brain. Once those constraints are lifted all bets are off. He introduces reasoning and decision making as functions of the brain (in addition to memory) and how the scope of inputs you can utilize is changing. We already know how people reason can be hugely impacted by where they live which limits the scope of what knowledge they have a priori. Ditto for who they know. And now we should also consider what information systems they have access to and choose to utilize.

So reasoning and decision making being functions of the brain he posits that how we do that and the results are now hugely impacted by a sphere of influence (physicality) far beyond the confines of their cranium. That influence is now decreasing our independence of reasoning and ability to form new contrarian ideas so reducing our ability to problem solve through diversity and exploration of alternatives, which even if surfaced occasionally are pounded back below grade by the hive "mind" of external influences.

@prometheus
What you are, in a round about way, talking about there is Steve Hanson's BITE model used by cults and ideologies to control their adherents.
Isolate your targets from all outside influence then cause peer pressure to influence the idea of "acceptable" Behaviour, Information, Thought and Emotion
That is not new or even novel, George Orwell was writing about it in the 1940s thirty years before Hanson formalised it.

You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:593529
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.