Agnostic.com

10 3

So this week my intellectual focus has been on the seemingly inevitable, transactional nature of human relationships. The only unconditional love I can see in practice is parental love. Is this true though? The alternative is that parental love is actually a result of ancient instinctual behavior, the residue of which has thus far survived our evolution. A pets love is probably instinctual as well, but if you lock your spouse and your pet in a car trunk for 2 hours, guess which one would be happier to see you when you finally let them out.

Seminarian 7 Apr 21
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

10 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

So true! I love my dog and she's always thrilled to see me!

1

Most of our major functions, like "love", are probably adaptive, but a few thousand years ago somebody figured out that we could go dancing on the spandrels; that there is potential functionality in the spaces between adaptations. We have the ability to use our adaptations in ways they were not evolved to be used. Then, known "spandrel-dances" became aggregated and codified into practices that proved to benefit individuals and societies. Those practices were exalted for their apparent supernatural capacities (natural = adaptation, supernatural = spandrel?) and evolved into religions. Then religious organizations accumulated power, which corrupted them, etc., etc. But one of those spandrel-dances was unconditional love. Before the corruption set in, unconditional love was rightly raised to sacred status. It is not instinctive. It is learned. It is possible. And it carries potential benefit for the practitioner, as well as the practitioner's community. But it is not "natural". It requires training. Parental love is natural.

skado Level 9 Apr 22, 2018
0

Hello there. I think that a modicum of transactionality is necessary to be able to exist and help others. Everything we do is physically limited by the laws of nature and psychologically governed by our ability to make decisions within the limits of those laws of nature. It’s perfectly fine that everyone has a way out or the power to say “thats’s it.” That’s what makes what people do for us worthy of our gratitude, and what in turn makes people grateful to us. And gratitude is a lovely thing to see.

0

Love always has conditions if it doesn't then doesn't that make it dogmatic?

2

I have experienced Unconditional Love from both sides; giving and receiving. It is the most incredible feeling.

0

I believe so although a couple who are truly bonded can get through almost anything.

0

A p[erson who would lok his wife, or even his cat, in the trunk of a car for 2 hours does not deserve to be loved.

1

I Agree completely.... Parental love is unconditional if the person does not jave psychological problems and is abusive.... not all people gave that nuture gene that you need to be a good parent.

WhoMe Level 4 Apr 21, 2018
1

Can't say I believe in the concept of unconditional love.

0

Hmm. I'm hoping the car trunk episode here is metaphorical... in any case, best wishes.

skado Level 9 Apr 21, 2018

I changed the word wife into spouse in deference to modernity. Just an old joke.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:62986
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.