Agnostic.com

6 3

Evolution only responds to the current situation, it has no foresight. Therefore if the environment in which an organism lives changes, especially suddenly, it is bound to be badly adapted to the new environment. And it may take millions of year of struggling before it becomes efficient and well adapted to its new circumstances.

Humans probably began to talk and develop language and culture, only in the last million years or two, in a major way, only in the last few thousand. And language, the culture it creates and technology, have caused perhaps the biggest and most rapid change to any animals environment that, probably, any animal ever survived. We are therefore most likely completely ill adapted to the new world in which we now live. Like pandas, which were meat eating bears, who took to eating bamboo quite recently, and now struggle to survive on a diet their gut is ill adapted to digest.

So we have a desire for high value food which was rare on the plains of Africa. But now that same desire when sugar and meat are easy to get, probably kills millions every year.

But the biggest change which took place when we began using language, was that we gained a vastly greater power to, create and spread, lies and fantasies. Our new environment is now awash with vast amounts of fiction and untruth, which we create at little cost. And of course because it all happened in a twinkling of an eye, as a side effect of an adaption, which was designed originally, for practical things, like helping us make better hunting plans. We have no instinctive safeguards against it, no sceptical instincts built in, we have no defenses against fiction, we are made to be deceived used and manipulated, by anyone with a voice.

Fernapple 9 Dec 12
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

6 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

quote

But the biggest change which took place when we began using language, was that we gained a vastly greater power to, create and spread, lies and fantasies.

Knowledge is bigger but wisdom often wanders off, we know not where.

1

Almost true.

"We are therefore most likely completely ill adapted to the new world in which we now live."

Not "completely". Substantially.

Substantially enough to put us in danger of extinction if we don't use that brain to modify our behavior culturally, which is our uniquely human "rapid response mechanism" to the evolutionary mismatch of which you speak.

skado Level 9 Dec 12, 2021

That is perfectly true. Substantially would be far better.

And this is why it is so important to teach critical thinking skills, and turn our backs on old corrupt institutions such as theism. Though that will probably happen anyway by the normal actions of history, it is just a question of soon enough and completely enough.

1

"we have no defenses against fiction, we are made to be deceived used and manipulated, by anyone with a voice."

to consider - seems to me like we have plenty of "fiction defenses". Yet, as vulnerable as we can be in some circumstances, (immaturity, pride for ex.) we are also very capable of deceiving and manipulating anyone with an ear.

Yes we do have defences, but of course we have to learn those. In the context, having "no defenses" I intend to mean only inherited instinctive defenses.

those instinctive defenses don't stand against fictions do they? fictions being a product of imagined thinking.

2

biological evolution can take eons, cognitive evolution can happen in a second.

im still trying to adapt to the new IHOP menus.

1

Given this, and the fact that selfishness is bred into the winners of her evolutionary process, I've been thinking lately that it would take an extraordinary set of favorable circumstances for evolved beings elsewhere in the universe to not fall victim to the same self-destructive process we have. As a result, the classic idea of some super-evolved beings that live harmoniously with everything else and their environment, thus allowing them to pity us and our petty human emotions, seems so improbable to me.

1

I hear you.

Origins of language.

[en.wikipedia.org]

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:638802
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.