Agnostic.com

76 2

What is your response when you ask a christian to physically show you god as to believe in him and they say well, "show me air?"

vetty87 4 Apr 25
Share

Enjoy being online again!

Welcome to the community of good people who base their values on evidence and appreciate civil discourse - the social network you will enjoy.

Create your free account

76 comments (51 - 75)

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

I say, stop breathing for an hour, if I were to ask that question, which I wouldn't.

1

Why would you even originate a conversation like that?

DONT' BE AN ATH-HOLE

[agnostic.com]

1

Christians have enough nonsense without me making it easier for them to lie. As a young man I was taken in by this crap because the adults seemed to believe in it. Why would the adults lie? Since there is no evidence either way it appears they keep up the lie to avoid being gullible. Besides, look at centuries of us all that believed for some reason. Yes!

  1. People do not want to die
  2. Nobody wants to go to hell
    If I discuss "show me the air" with a Christian we are next into ideas that we breathe in god every day of our lives. If this is god and he is eternal then we are talking the universe which just might have always existed in some way.
    So much for useless god talk.
1

Air can be measured, just like gravity, radiation, heat, time, pressure, so on and so forth.

1

Air, among other things, can be felt. Secondly, allow me to place you in a container w/o air and you will know I don't need to show you "AIR".

1

My response would be to immidiately stop the conversation at that juncture, and seek conversation with someone who has a minimum of a double digit IQ level.

1

Show them your middle finger and say, "Behold!"

Athos Level 5 Apr 25, 2018

HAHAHAHA

1

I had never asked anyone to physically show me god. Respect Boundaries, Respect!

1

Off

1

Unfortunately, from my experiences, most theists are horribly science illiterate. I would say show them this, because air is oxygen.


Be prepared for pure dumbfoundedness.

Oxigen is a component of air.... Is Not Air!!! A "scientist" should know that!

@GipsyOfNewSpain yeah, yeah, yeah....well two of the highest concentrated components of air were in the video in liquid and visible form. Carbon Dioxide, Argon and other various gases make up for about 1%. And I'm sure most scientists do know it.

@SinCityHeathen what you do with liquid oxigen? Inject it in your lungs? Before diving? Should I carried it on a thermos around in church until somebody ask proof?

@GipsyOfNewSpain Yes, carry it to your nearest church and show them what Oxygen looks like. If you want to know the uses for liquid O2, Google it.

@SinCityHeathen You got me gasping for air right now! The militants!!!

1

I don't ask them anything. I just feel sorry for them.

1

I seldom to never confront others about their beliefs, unless they ask about my own. My wife took our three kids to church every Sunday, granted w/o kids we never went to church. And I never spoke of my beliefs with my kids, and now my son is Christian, but my two daughters like me.

1

Simple. Air is real. You can feel it, sometimes even see it. It's what we breath! As opposed to god, of which there is no proof it exists. Ask them to show you physical proof of a god. And then ask them, well why don't you believe in the tooth fairy? Its the same nonsense.

1

Fart and walk away .

1

I've asked someone to pray for god to come down here and make me an elephant. They said they can't.

1

We can at least to my knowledge measure air and it’s very applications. Like put a person in a chamber and remove the air then replace it. Also, if they are making a positive claim it’s on them to prove it.

1

You could be cheeky and ask them if they consider air to be their god ?

1

Then you can say"Hey, you can hear air too!"

1

I would say that proves nothing. There is nothing tangentially out there to prove theres a god.

1

I would never even ask such a question.

Coldo Level 8 Apr 25, 2018
1

I could do that but I don't think you would understand, it would be way over your head.

0

I always hate it when Christian people give me that retarded come back it's like you can't see the air blowing things around you can't feel it on your skin it's very obvious that it's real there's physical signs of it being there all you have to do is blow on your hand and you know it's there

0

In the Salt Lake Valley, many days you can see the air,,,,,I have often wondered how on earth people can trust air the can't see ?

0

Showing someone air can be done with a tank of liquid nitrogen and liquid oxygen. Requires some awesome cryogenics, but it's doable.

0

I hate it when ppl reject hypotheticals, easy blow a piece of paper.

Write Comment
You can include a link to this post in your posts and comments by including the text q:65911
Agnostic does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any content. Read full disclaimer.